I agree that the difference in sidewall and OD is minimal, but I wanted a little something extra all around. I have 285/45/22s on my lowered Tahoe and love the way they look. However, these trucks have a completely different look than Tahoes, so I don't mind the extra bulge around the rim (I know exactly what you're talking about. I saw that size on a Tahoe and thought they looked like balloons).
Very nice ride, by the way. I was debating between the CK158s and CK159s. You can't go wrong with either.