I think you're right, I'll post a picture hopefully tonight. There literally is no room for two pieces of hardware on the driver side, the top of the pad hits the steel of the caliper bracket without the top hardware. It's crazy. I'll definitely try a few more pad sets, that's literally the only thing I can think of.
You guys are great, thank you for the replies. If you think of anything else please let me know. I have truly never seen this happen (brake pad not fitting super easy) unless it was a half year vehicle(worked at Merlin's here in Chicago for 6+ months and did tons of brake jobs) so it's really perplexing.