New guy here. I've been enjoying reading this post. I have owned a bunch of vehicles over the past 15 years for various reasons. My job required me to have a fairly new vehicle up until last year when they got us all company vehicles. In that timeframe, I had a '00 Suburban, '03 Silverado 1500, '11 Sierra crew cab with a Duramax and a '14 crew cab Silverado 1500, and my wife currently has a '07 Yukon XL. Now that I can have what I want, I traded my last truck in to get some cash out of it and go back to a Suburban, which was my favorite of the bunch.
Here are the reasons I went back to the GMT800.
1. Interior. I know there's a lot of chunky looking plastic, but the layout is my favorite. Everything is easy to reach and easy to "feel" while driving so I can keep my eyes on the road. Even though the GMT900 is supposed to be an upgraded interior, both the high end dash in my wife's and the basic dash in the '11 were pretty flimsy. The seats fit me better. It feels more roomy than my wife's '07 not just up front, but everywhere, especially in the back.
2. Ride and handling. The '14 was by far the best driving of the bunch, but the GMT800 have been pretty close. My wife's has quite a bit of oversteer and not much feedback. I can easily load up the front end and corner well in my '05 compared to the '07 that's a little hard to predict. I actually think my Duramax handled better than our '07 (everything is tight and aligned with new quick struts). I also like the fact that almost everything in the suspension is greasable. My '00 Suburban had all OE parts when I got rid of it with 180k miles.
3. Power train. I'm not a fan of the DOD and VVT. My wife's had the slugs replaced right before we bought it, so I think we're good. I will concede that the Castech head issue can be bad. The heads on the newer 5.3 are far superior performance wise too. I love the 6.2 in the newer trucks too (Maybe that's pushing me towards the GMT900). I've had two of the 6L80s and neither seemed to do too well. I had a G8 GT in the mix and it shifted horribly until I had it tuned, and it still had some issues finding the right gear and sometimes it just wouldn't shift into reverse. The '14 Silverado was worse. Not to mention, I can get a nice 4L65E for way less than the 6 speed.
4. Styling. I prefer the body lines to the GMT900. I couldn't catch on to the fender flair profile on either version. Totally subjective.
So, there you have it. Totally just my opinion. Either way, GM makes the best trucks, no matter what year!