I love the ingenuity of what you're trying to do, but there's a small issue that would still exist.
You would essentially be creating a solid lifter to replace the hydraulic one. Making up for the overall travel by extending the pushrod. All that is fine.
The issue is presented when you have seven hydraulic lifters and one solid lifter. Technically, the oil is meant to pass through the pushrod to lubricate the lifter seat, and the lifter bore as well as provide oil for the hydraulic function. When going to a solid lifter, oil still passes to the lifter through the pushrod so the lifter bore is lubed properly. Another issue with this, is that as lifters wear over time, their ability to hold the same hydraulic pressure fades, but even more so, the speed the pressure hits its maximum takes longer and longer. RPM causes the same event at times, and in a severe enough instance will cause valve float.
All of the above is minimized due to all lifters being hydraulic. They each have a small about of give and take depending on several variables. If you have one that's solid, there's no longer an operating range, instead it becomes 100% static. That may not cause any major issues for quite some time. If nothing else, I can't imagine it not making a ton of noise.
I'm not saying it can't be done, and I'm sure someone will jump on here saying I'm completely wrong, but I would not recommend doing it. Especially when all you have to do is turn AFM off ahead of time to prevent having the issue at all.
Just my two cents.