I’ve run the Nitto Trail Grapplers and the Nitto Ridge Grapplers and have nothing but good things to say about both of them. They balance very easily and I’ve gotten a lot of miles out of them. The Trail Grappler is a mud terrain so they do have a hum to them, but the Ridge Grapplers an all terrain and are very quiet. And the Ridge Grappler has the same sidewalk as the Trail Grappler. So based on your request for a good all terrain that looks like a mud tire, the Ridge Grappler would be the best tire in my opinion.