I have owned both gas and diesel 2020+ HD trucks. I currently own a 2024 gas 3500 that I traded a 2023 3500 diesel for and have a gas ZR2 on order that will hopefully be here soon. I use my truck as a daily driver but also pull my 12,000lb 5th wheel around 10,000 miles a year.
I’ve pulled it with both gas and diesel all over the eastern United States from the flatlands southeastern us to the mountains of Virginia and WV. The gas is more than enough for 99% of HD truck buyers. No def, no emissions related issues, cheaper fuel. Also me personally, I average about 14.5-16 mpg unloaded with my gas on my daily commute. I averaged 15ish with the diesel. Towing I average 8.5-9.5 with the gas and averaged 9.5-10.5 with the diesel. So no real MPG benefit for me. Also save about $11,000 upfront compared to the diesel.
For me it’s a nobrainer but if you’re pulling 15,000lbs plus on a daily basis, sure get the diesel. If you live out west and climb 8000-10,000 ft regularly? Get the diesel. But as for me, GAS all day.
The diesel certainly has its place, I’m just honest enough with myself to know that I don’t need it.
You will get the occasional person that says “hey nice truck.” And then followed by “Oh man, you don’t have the diesel!”
At the end of the day, your money, your choice. I for one, don’t care to get other dudes rocked up at the red light over the chitter chatter of my duramax.