So as far as I know it’s the slider frame that has the leak. Unless it was a bad window seal job from the factory. The solid windows don’t leak. That being said after pulling the spoiler I would recommend doing this regardless. The yellow tabs have a thin seal and the stud that aligns the spoiler has that crappy foam that was soaked all the way. 3m rope seal is a great product that stays workable for years. I left my headliner down and flooded the roof and no leaks. Problem is the dealership will only repair what GM tells them. After one visit and reading what happens to your interior with the sloppiness I won’t ever go that route again