So I will try to help here as I have been tuning using hptuners and see first hand results of using a sealed catch can, vented catch can or free air venting the cc, or utilizing the stock PCV system. Using a sealed can improves performance and longevity like a vented can does but still allows a slight amount of carbon buildup on the valves of a DI engine. I’ve seen the stock pcv system cause preignition due to carbon deposits on the spark plugs and combustion chamber. This obviously hurts gas mileage and performance. When venting the cc to atmosphere and giving the engine a nice treatment of seafoam, the preignition caused by the ingestion of oil vapors disappeared and performance returned. Using a sealed catch can is better than not using any sort of modification at all and worth it from my experiences. I’ve ran my cc vents to atmosphere on all of my vehicles since I’ve started tuning engines and I will continue to do so to keep engine cleanliness and longevity as long as possible. The only reason the OEM uses a pvc system is for emissions purposes and nothing more. If OEM would use some sort of small injector that soaks the intake valves periodically to clean them around service intervals (like the fuel injectors in port fuel injection engines use to do full time) this carbon buildup wouldn’t be an issue for the longevity of the valvetrain and engine performance for the most part. Venting the cc to atmosphere is second best to using a high volume vacuum pump pulling a vacuum on the cc at WOT not recirculating the oil vapor back into the intake tract. I work on race cars all the time and though the tech they use in most of them is nothing new, it’s because the EPA doesn’t care learn how to not hurt the performance of fossil fuel burning engines. I’ve seen engines without emissions equipment produce less harmful emissions than some bone stock vehicles with catalytic converters and a functioning pcv system. Downside to running the little pod filters off the valve covers is misting the top of the valve covers with oil vapor which will collect dust and make a mess with time. Also if you do this, there will be a vacuum leak and DTC if you don’t plug the little port going to the intake manifold from the pcv tube and venting the cc vent under the tb to atmosphere as well as the vents on the fronts of the valve covers. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk