So here is my take on this whole thing. I have found that GM likes to spin me in circles and heres why. When I was first advised to call GM customer care and start a case number I was assigned a customer service manager.. Every time I would ask this person for an update she would have to call the dealer and talk to them and then give me a call back a day later.. The information I was given was the same information I would get if I called the dealer and asked my self. Over time I found this was pretty much useless.. This is when I decided to take things to the next step and Email Marry Barra. I sent a lengthy email about what I had been through with a time line of events and who I spoke to. A day or two later I received a call from an executive office manager and was told she was now assigned to my case by Marry Barra and she would be relay the info back to Mrs. Barra. Well over time I came to find out that she was pretty much the same type of customer service person as the last one.. Would have to call the dealer to find out what was going on then relay the message back to me a day later. After a few weeks of talking to her I found she had no authorization to make any decisions in my case she was simply following along to relay information. As things progressed and I now had been going back and forth with her, the general manager, the service manager, and the owner of the dealership I had came to the conclusion is that the District manager of after sales(DMA) is the one who clearly is the decider of my fate with this truck. Once I filed my BBB case the executive office rep stopped contacting me and the DMA took any offers off the table. At this point I was told that no one could talk to me anymore because it is now a legal case. I got a call from GMs resolution department (extremely rude by the way) and was offered what the state would have allowed for a trade in only if I would have won arbitration. I told them this was a worse deal than I had already been offered. Through talking with this person I had found out that he was receiving orders from the DMA her self after I was told by her she couldn't talk to me any more it was in the hands of someone else! WTF GM...
I filed my final attempt which is a requirement for the lemon law. They replaced all the tires and shocks and called it fixed even though it is not and is supposedly "within specs from 0-70mph". So now I have put my BBB case on hold and I am waiting to work with the DMA again to get into another truck because at this point I had decided it would be easier to take a 2015 2500 and call it a day because I would have went and probably bought one anyways after I got my money back. I really am over their games and If this doesn't get resolved quick I am going full force on a lemon law and I will buy another brand. This is their last chance to make this right. The lawyer I had sent my documents to for counsel is chomping at the bit for this case and wants me to pursue lemon law.
Now GM knows if they buy back a truck and give you your money back there going to lose their ass on the truck if its lemon titled so I believe they are trying to buy these trucks back under trade in assistance to prevent this. The reason I recommend everyone send an email to Mary Barra and the NHSTA is because we will not get any where if there is no pressure put on GM to fix these trucks. Marry Barra's mailbox should be full of our complaints so that she understands how wide spread the problem is and puts the pressure on the right people. If only one or two people here or there complain our problems will get dismissed as we are just complainers and they will still use the excuse "oh this is the first time I've heard of this problem."
My recommendation at this point is to try and work with the DMA if your willing to get into another GM vehicle. I my self will not take another 1500, 2014 or 2015, I don't trust the platform. I have however driven a few Duramax's and from what I understand is that it is the same frame, engine, and transmission that they have been using for the past 4-5 years so the kinks I'm assuming are worked out. The only thing that would make me nervous is the rest of the truck. Am I happy about being forced to spend another 5-6k to get a working truck? Hell no!! But at this point its this option for a proven drive train or to go through the hassle and time of going through arbitration, and possibly a law suit thats going to drag this on for another 3-4 months. I WILL go that route if they don't step up and make me happy as the customer service has been SHIT so far.