Doing some digging with my weather station data (smarthome), I found the following:
From my smart plug that triggered the block heater, I "plugged it in" at 8:33AM
Real weather data pulled from weather station sensor on my roof at 8:30am says +2.0 degrees F, while my smart mirror (openweathermap data) said -5.28 at 8:24AM (so I fed them wrong information here).
Again, my weather station said that at 9:30AM, the temp outside was +2.4 degrees F, but openweathermap says -1.86 at 9:34 (again I told them it was negative temps when I started it because I was looking at openweathermap data, not the sensor outside my window, but in reality it was above 0F).
I looked back at the video I took at 9:32AM of me starting the truck to confirm the actual start time today.
I called the dealer back and notified of the actual temperatures, not the openweathermap temps as this is vital to the troubleshooting process I'm sure.