I used to have a 2022 F-250 Lariat SuperCrew FX4 w/ 7.3L
*F-250 was taken out (totaled) in a violent hail storm last spring. We're talking golf ball to baseball size hail. Horrible. So thankful for Insurance!
After a lot of research and shopping, I decided to buy a 2024 GMC 2500HD AT4 w/ L8T ('Allison' 10spd).
Here are my observations now that I've owned both Ford and GM Heavy Duty gassers w/ 10 speed:
The drivetrain in the GMC is a bit smoother. The "Allison" transmission shifts smoother, feels a bit higher in overall quality. Shifting from Park -> Reverse, Reverse -> Drive, Drive -> Park, etc is smoother in the Allison vs the Ford 10R140. ALL the shifting is very very nice in the Allison. I didn't have any issues with the Ford 10R140, but the Allison feels like an upgrade. I do wish the GM would display what gear you're in (Ford does this). Definitely a transmission win for GM!
The ride is a definitely smoother in the GMC, as it has independent front suspension vs the Ford's solid front axle. This makes a very noticeable difference in daily driving a HD truck!
Exterior and Interior design (personal preference of course): I like the GMC AT4 better. Especially when you consider the 2023 Ford Super Duty design. I feel Ford missed on the 2022 -> 2023 redesign. Again, this is just personal preference and opinion.
The 6.6L L8T revs quicker and is quieter. Not that I was looking for a quieter V8. Just an observation.
The mpg seems to be about the same between the two (~ 14 mpg average in city/hwy). Highway in my area is 70 to 75mph speed limits....so not pokey (ie not ideal for fuel economy). Also I drive a lot in stop/go traffic.
I can feel the -29 hp reduction in power with the 6.6L (not horrible, but I think the Ford was a little faster). Off the line acceleration = GM is faster (but that is mostly due to 3.73 gears vs Ford 3.55 gears (2023+ F-250 offers 3.73 or 4.30).
The 2024 GM 2500HD is a heavier truck (7472 lbs) vs the 2022 F-250 (6800 lbs). So my GM is 672 lbs heavier!
7.3L Godzilla 430 hp, 475 lb-ft (2023+ 485 lb-ft)
6.6L L8T 401 hp, 464 lb-ft.
2024 GMC 2500HD CrewCab AT4:
*my specific truck
Payload = 3378 lbs
Conventional Towing = 16,000 lbs
2022 F-250 Lariat SuperCrew FX4:
*my specific truck
Payload = 2983 lbs
Conventional Towing = 14,500 lbs.
For those that work on their own vehicles, the one thing that I was surprised to discover was that GM 'wax dips' their frames vs e-Coat Paint. When working on the GMC (greasing front suspension) it is easy to get the oily wax all over your arms. Not a bad thing per say. Just wish GM would e-coat their frames (like Ford) and not use the messy wax coating that rubs off on you so easily.
Conclusion:
Overall I like the GMC better.
Nothing really bad to say about the 2022 F-250, EXCEPT that I did notice some rough idling on occasion in the 7.3L....the internet 'lifter' concerns were in the back of my mind when that would happen. Was it an actual issue? I don't know.
My 6.6L L8T is not using oil (as this is a reported issue for some out there). I think this is mostly on 2020, 2021 trucks?
I've read many people say their truck does NOT have this oil consumption issue. So it might just be internet amplification (like the lifter issue probably is on the 7.3L)?
I've been a loyal Ford customer for 20+ years...so going GMC was a big deal to me. So far I'm very happy with my decision to buy the GMC 2500HD (6.6L L8T w/ Allison)!