I am in a somewhat similar position, was so excited to drive it home. Great condition GM company vehicle and CPO 2018 with 7000 miles. Mine misfires/misses, local independent mechanic told me yes he can easily feel it but no codes for it. Folks on these forums are sharing that is very common to rough idle like that but my 2 test drives I did show that they can idle butter smooth. Selling dealer told me - “no codes, nothing to fix, all 8- cylinder engines are like that, just live with it...” Why are you are you even thinking about trading it in for another GM? Chances are you can get a smooth idle with 2019 but feels like lottery, for me it is a lot of money to gamble with. I am seriously thinking about trading it in to older Nissan or Toyota 8-cylinder. I love how quiet my Yukon is, it has great looks. Almost everything I wanted except this idle. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro