So, I'm a big car guy. I've had numerous 5.3 and 6.2L trucks, last one was an '18 6.2 SLT Z71. A buddy tricked me into trading it for a '19 Raptor, first truck on the dark side. It's alright and a great truck, but the engine note sucks, good power though.
Anyway, I digress. So, been working with my Dad on trading his 2015 Sierra Denali 6.2/8speed on a new 2020 Sierra Denali. We drove the Rams and F-150 to be fair, but meh. Nice interior on the Dodge, but crazy valvetrain noise (oiling issue) on remote start of one we drove. Crazy.. F-150 is a good truck obviously, but they weren't discounting much and the Limited was expensive as heck and looked a little boring (i.e. like most F-150's) We went back and forth between the 6.2 and 3.0 numerous times. Well, he picked up his 2020 Sierra Denali 3.0 diesel this past Friday. It's awesome.
Unless you are doing high rpm highway pulls and need the top-end acceleration of the 6.2, the 3.0 turbodiesel is freaking fun around town and has more "real world" torque in the rpm range 95% of truck drivers operate. It clicks through the gears in the 10 speed and always stays in the meat of the powerband. It's BUTTER smooth, quiet, and is just a freaking awesome engine. 460lb/ft at 1,500rpm versus same torque at 4,100rpm in the 6.2. Only time you notice the horsepower deficit is full throttle acceleration and racing. Even then, the diesel chugs through the gears and gets up to speed nicely riding that fat torque wave, but it will get pulled by a 6.2 in a race, no question about it.
I'm a huge horsepower nut (have owned my now 663rwhp (E85, headers, tune, pulleys) 2010 ZR1 since new and just love hauling butt and think the 6.2 is a top shelf engine. But, the 3.0 turbodiesel is better in 99% of real world situations than the 6.2 in my humble opinion. I'm so glad I talked my Dad into it. Plus, it's $1500 cheaper now which is a nice little bonus. ?
Drive one and drive it normally like you would in regular situations and it will feel like the better engine for sure. So smooth and so nice. However, if you hop in a 6.2 and floor it all over town and then hop in the 3.0 and try to floor it all over town, you will be disappointed in the 3.0. Beyond that extreme scenario, the 3.0 turbodiesel will come out the winner IMHO.