I have headers with no cats, then magnaflow 12909 3.5 in and 3.5 out. I cut the flapper valve out as soon as I tuned out the AFM years ago. I just cut the rear resonator off myself and left it dumped over the rear axle. I find this is a really good combo with lots of volume at WOT but quiet at cruising speed with no drone.
Before I had headers. I had the 12909 muffler, no flapper valve and the rear resonator cut off. This was only slightly louder than stock with this muffler but much deeper. But I knew I was adding headers with a catless Y pipe later. And knew from my last truck that would wake it up alot.
The stock Y pipe has three cats in it. This makes it to quiet.