I agree with most of what you said. My only comment, as a long term Duramax owner, to those weighing gas vs. diesel, mileage, capabilities etc..is that the emissions systems aren't "fickle" as to suggest they are on the edge of failing at any time, they aren't. Buy for what your needs are, drive both and decide if the extra cost is worth the diesel. The diesel also carries a 100,000 mile powertrain warranty where gas is only 60,000. Just something that might narrow the gap if anything goes bad on the gas version after 60,000 that you'll pay out of pocket. (not likely as the GM gas trucks are rock solid) but something else to consider.