When my diesel was down, i drove the gas truck and it was significantly more thirsty while towing. I pull the same trailer many weekends to my cabin and the gas truck barely made it, while my Duramax would still have over half a tank..nothing scientific just real world experience, Like I was saying as a response to the original post, IMO if towing 8k in the mountains, I’d buy the diesel and in that scenario (mountain towing) you would miss the exhaust brake. The diesel is much quieter and hums along barely breaking a sweat, the gasser felt like it was really working hard..high revs, noticeable shifting etc..BUT it did get the job done.
The issue my Dmax had was an electrical problem with DEF tank heater, yes emissions related, but more of a supplier issue with the def tank change, This is the 1st Duramax that I’ve had an issue with so hopefully it will be good to go now. I agree though, certainly more to go wrong with the diesel. That and the initial cost of the truck is why we went for gas trucks. Again offer a 10spd with the gas and I’m interested.