Had mine in twice to fix. Dealer was nothing but top notch with my issue. First attempt was a seal. It ended up leaking a bit worse.
After notifying them with pics, they order new window, headliner and trim pieces (and a wheel, separate story). Parts took forever to get in. They had to re-ship the headliner 3 times as the first two had creases from transit. They offered me a loaner each time. My truck was out in a week and a day.
Both are beautiful colors. Either way you decide, I'm sure you'll be happy. Me personally, I'd get the Silver Ice but If you can't come to
a firm decision, you can go with the one that's cheaper? ?