A couple updates:
1) Worked out a deal with another forum member to sell the intake. He's getting a practically brand-new intake for a good price, win-win.
2) Beware of Moore Racing Technology in Nevada who I bought this intake from. aFe actually said they would accept the intake back as a return, but I would have to do it through the seller. After two emails, multiple unanswered phone calls, and a Facebook message that was read within minutes of me sending it, MRT has never responded to any of my attempts to communicate with them.
3) I instead modified the stock airbox by cutting out some of the stock filter box plastic that blocks airflow in from the fender well, and installed a Green Filter #2006 drop-in oiled filter into the stock airbox. Although it doesn't feel quite like the aFe did, it definitely feels better than stock, especially with throttle response.