Trim and tires effect this. Non AT4 and especially non Duratracs would give about 2-3 more mpg. Those 2 items add a lot of wind drag and rolling weight for the tires. With that said I am a direct comparison as my TB had duratracs as well.
I will add that my lifetime went up to 22.4 yesterday with basically just small town driving yesterday.
I will add that I drove my 6.2 like it deserved to be drove at times. That motor was fun. As the 3.0 is just getting broken in I have started to get on the pedal heavier.
Regardless my lifetime right now is slightly more than a 7 mpg gain. Diesel around here is the same (or cheaper) than premium. 160-170 extra miles per tank. Roughly saving me $20-25 per tank.
I believe that the silverado gets slightly better MPG as it is a little more aerodynamic.
I will also add that the 10sp transmission is a game changer. smooth. always seems to be in the right gear. definitely helps with the economy. I have had 6 and 8 sp GM transmissions, tundra 6 sp, ram 8 sp and by far the 10 speed is the best 1/2 ton transmission I have driven.
I am curious to see what 14k of mileage looks like on the 3.0 for more accurate comparison.