Before you go an buy one and swap out. Try taking the rubber piece out and flip it around. so the lip is in the front. I was having trouble charging my S8 in my 2016, but after I turned the rubber piece around it charges just fine. It moves the phone closer to the back about a 1/4 inch. Just enough to hit the sweet spot on the charger. You will have to cut off a small nub on the bottom of the pad that is used for alignment. Very easy mod and works like a charm every time I pop the phone down now.