Wow! What a thread. I had forgotten how immature and "macho" some of the people are on this site. I wonder how many of you have truck nuts hanging from the back?
If you answered that one engine is better than another, then you don't know what you're talking about. All of the engines are fine. Their reliability is basically equal. They're just suited to different tasks and different people. Nobody can answer that question for somebody else. For some people the 4.3L will be the best engine, for others the 6.2L. It's a simple concept
Not one engine can do everything asked of it. The 6.2L makes gobs of power, but it's expensive to own and operate given the up front cost, premium gas, and crappy fuel economy. That's not for everybody. The 4.3L is great on mileage and light truck duty, but wouldn't be a good choice for somebody looking to tow or carry heavy loads regularly. The 5.3L is a good compromise between the two. Buy the engine that suites your personal needs.