Wow, after reading several pages of this over and over I decided to go with the Pace Edwards retractable. I believe the lund covers are the best for protection, the only draw back is bulkiness and having to remove when needed. The keys for me is sleekness, flush mount. the only things that I didn't like about the panels is that they covered the rear window. I am now on search of permanent type cargo manager like roll-n-lock offers. roll-n-lock says it only works with their rail system, which I think can be worked around !!!