It seems that Carvana wants to offer more for my 2.5 year old '18 Sierra SLT than I paid for it new (other than tax). It is making me consider an upgrade to a Denali Ultimate or a loaded up AT4.
I tow a 5000ish lb boat. Most of my towing is a 2 mile drive maxing at 45MPH, where the 2.7L 4 banger would suffice. But about twice a year we do a 700 mile round trip going through the Kentucky and Tennessee mountains. On those trips, we are loaded with gear and around 7000lbs total with gear/passengers. I will also likely upgrade to a bit larger boat in the next couple of years, expecting that number to climb to 8000lbs. I may also begin racing/towing my car, but that will end up being lighter than the boat.
I'm happy with the 6.2L / 8-speed tranny combo I have today. I know I will be happy with the 6.2L / 10-speed combo. Will I be happy with the diesel? I don't put a lot of miles on the truck (10,500 in 2.5 years). The diesels are more plentiful and significantly cheaper. I can get a crew AT4 with Tech, Driver Alert II, Sunroof, AT4 value, tow mirrors, with the diesel for $54,500 out the door (plus tax). About $3500ish more for a Denali Ultimate.
Thoughts on one engine vs the other? I was planning on keeping my current truck 5-10 years and if it wasn't for today's stupid high resale, I wouldn't be considering getting rid of it as it has been a great.