Replace one or both leaf springs?

[lehardee]

I took my 2014 Silverado with nearly 36k on it to the dealer again for noise in the leaf springs or shackles. They determined they will need to replace the driver side leaf spring. Of course they don't want to "spring" for replacing the passenger side to match. Question is, should I man up and pay for the passenger side? Is it "standard practice" to replace the pair? If this wasn't a warranty (just barely) repair, would the dealership recommend replacing both?

 

Thanks in advance!

[Heavy 5.7]

Obviously you would replace both sides, are the inserts still in place?

[lehardee]

If by inserts you mean the round insulator pads, then yes.