Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Please share some insight into my recent oil analysis. Oil type is unknown, was last changed at the dealership before I purchased the truck. Over 79,000 miles on the motor, 4,200 miles on oil when sampled/changed.

 

No current issues, oil burning minimal. Just wanted to get a baseline.

20 SIERRA 1500-250510-edit (1).pdf

Posted

Total wear metals come in at 6.9 ppm/K miles. Iron alone is almost 5 ppm/K miles. 

Base on the Universal Averages 6.4 ppm/K total wear metals and 3.1 ppm/K iron are their benchmarks. 

What does that indicate to you? 

 

Some critical information is missing. TBN and Oxidation and any VOA data so we know what is background and what is wear.

 

Hint: With the recent increases in Blackstone Labs pricing AND lack of critical information AND crackle test for water and flash cups for fuel; you will find @Black02Silverado can set you up with a cheaper and more complete and accurate test. 

 

Outside the fact that this motor is running close to Universal Averages doesn't mean meaningful improvement can't be made in wear. Your past warranty, yes? No? If so believe GM. Start using a decent 0W40 or at least a 3.5 minimum HTHS 5W30 (ACEA C3). 

 

Will it fall apart if you don't? No. It will just live longer if you do. How long is your choice. And find an oil with some solvency or that little bit of oil consumption will become something other... Valvoline Restore and Protect 5W30 would be a good fist shot even though it isn't a polar oil. It does it's cleaning by other chemical means and while not 3.5 it is 3.3 HTHS which is a vast improvement over the 2.6 HTHS oil now in it. 4K OCI without TBN seems safe. 

 

Now let the rain begin. :crackup:That's my story and I'm sticking to it. 😬

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2
Posted (edited)

Thanks @Grumpy Bear. That iron ppm is exactly why I posted. I'll look deeper into which oil (0w40 or 5w30) and brand will be my next move. I don't know what HTHS is, but I'll go do my own research on that.. Who knows what oil the dealership would have used that was in it previously.. 

 

Interested to learn more about the analysis @Black02Silverado offers.

Edited by BainMan
  • Like 1
Posted
8 hours ago, BainMan said:

Thanks @Grumpy Bear. That iron ppm is exactly why I posted. I'll look deeper into which oil (0w40 or 5w30) and brand will be my next move. I don't know what HTHS is, but I'll go do my own research on that.. Who knows what oil the dealership would have used that was in it previously.. 

 

Interested to learn more about the analysis @Black02Silverado offers.

I can get you Oil Analizers used oil kits. The best price is to be a Preferred Customer. I can get you set up. I just need your name,address,email address and phone number. You can send it in a PM. 

Posted
12 hours ago, BainMan said:

Please share some insight into my recent oil analysis. Oil type is unknown, was last changed at the dealership before I purchased the truck. Over 79,000 miles on the motor, 4,200 miles on oil when sampled/changed.

 

No current issues, oil burning minimal. Just wanted to get a baseline.

20 SIERRA 1500-250510-edit (1).pdf 18.38 kB · 18 downloads

 

 

Some things to keep in mind. 1.) And average is just that. When they give you one there are motors below and above that nominal value. 2.) Each motor platform and even state of factory tune can have a large impact on the actual values. Not every power cylinder is laid out the same. Ring choice, bore hardness and material type, etc. This may be good for that motor with that oil. Not alarming. But you MAY be able to improve those results. 

Posted
On 6/10/2025 at 9:41 AM, BainMan said:

Thanks @Grumpy Bear. That iron ppm is exactly why I posted. I'll look deeper into which oil (0w40 or 5w30) and brand will be my next move. I don't know what HTHS is, but I'll go do my own research on that.. Who knows what oil the dealership would have used that was in it previously.. 

 

Interested to learn more about the analysis @Black02Silverado offers.

Bainman, ask Nick, @Black02Silverado about the air leak sucking dust in around your air filter system ( maybe air filter itself ?) from this analysis. No one seems to correlate that to iron wear level. Insolubles in 4200 miles too high. 
I’d correct dust leak and run Valvoline Restore Clean and Protect 0w-20 for an interval. 
 


 

Posted
On 6/10/2025 at 9:41 AM, BainMan said:

Thanks @Grumpy Bear. That iron ppm is exactly why I posted. I'll look deeper into which oil (0w40 or 5w30) and brand will be my next move. I don't know what HTHS is, but I'll go do my own research on that.. Who knows what oil the dealership would have used that was in it previously.. 

 

Interested to learn more about the analysis @Black02Silverado offers.

Drop by here and get a proper interpretation ; 

 

 

Posted

@BainMan Silicon too high and is dirt causing increased iron wear especially for only having 4,200 miles on it. When was the last time the air filter was changed? 
Manganese and potassium are dirt that are knocking off fuel deposits and potassium chloride from salt .

 

With only 4,200 miles the insoldubles shouldn't be what it is and max of 0.2 or less.  What oil filter are you using?
 

Also, what fuel are you using?  Any chance to get E85 and mix it in?  I can run 9 gallons of E85 to a tank and not throw any check engine light codes.  Any higher and I get running lean on both banks.  It runs so much better using E85 like that. It also helps burn cleaner and has higher octane.  

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
  • 7 months later...
Posted
On 6/13/2025 at 8:30 AM, Black02Silverado said:

@BainMan Silicon too high and is dirt causing increased iron wear especially for only having 4,200 miles on it. When was the last time the air filter was changed? 
Manganese and potassium are dirt that are knocking off fuel deposits and potassium chloride from salt .

 

With only 4,200 miles the insoldubles shouldn't be what it is and max of 0.2 or less.  What oil filter are you using?
 

Also, what fuel are you using?  Any chance to get E85 and mix it in?  I can run 9 gallons of E85 to a tank and not throw any check engine light codes.  Any higher and I get running lean on both banks.  It runs so much better using E85 like that. It also helps burn cleaner and has higher octane.  

Somehow I missed your reply (a long time ago). Running Shell 93, but get the occasional Sam's Club 91 when I don't have time to make it across the river to the Shell. I've never considered mixing in E85.. Do you fill the rest of the tank with premium or is 89 good when mixing E85? 

 

Air filter looked clean after purchasing the truck, so I have not changed it.. I took it out and combed through looking for debris. It looked like the dealership changed it, or it was recently changed prior to them getting it.  I'll add it to the list though, I don't like not knowing how many miles are on it..  

 

Oil filter - Purolator PL22500 with Mobil 1 0w-20 High Mileage. 

 

I'm 3,000 miles into this oil change, may consider getting it analyzed again at 4,000... 

 

Posted
9 hours ago, BainMan said:

Somehow I missed your reply (a long time ago). Running Shell 93, but get the occasional Sam's Club 91 when I don't have time to make it across the river to the Shell. I've never considered mixing in E85.. Do you fill the rest of the tank with premium or is 89 good when mixing E85? 

 

Air filter looked clean after purchasing the truck, so I have not changed it.. I took it out and combed through looking for debris. It looked like the dealership changed it, or it was recently changed prior to them getting it.  I'll add it to the list though, I don't like not knowing how many miles are on it..  

 

Oil filter - Purolator PL22500 with Mobil 1 0w-20 High Mileage. 

 

I'm 3,000 miles into this oil change, may consider getting it analyzed again at 4,000... 

 

OK, it would be good to see the UOA.  It's not expensive and so I would change out the air filter.

 

As for E85, I put in 9 gallons and then fill up with 93 but 89 would work just as good I would imagine.  The E85 is what boost the octane anyway.

  • Like 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • Thanks - I wasn't quite caffeinated this morning. 2:1 makes sense, turning the crankshaft 360 degrees will turn the cam 180 degrees, and had I done that, the cam's dot would be at 6 and the crank's at 12 again.   I went ahead and took the sprocket off anyway, aligned everything dot-to-dot including the balance shaft just for s&g. I'm glad I did because I discovered no Loctite on the timing sprocket bolts. Maybe it's not required, but at only 20 ft-lb torque spec, those bolts aren't in there very tight. Cleaned and reassembled with some thread locker and torqued.   A general observation: Less is more with RTV. If a little doesn't stop a leak, a LOT probably won't, either. RTV is thinly veiled revenge, in a tube...      
    • The timing marks are ok, that is #1, you can turn it over until they line up and it won't change anything, the crankshaft turns twice for every camshaft revolution, I have always set up SB Chevs as your pic shows using a straight edge
    • Someone's been here before.... There is a receipt for a 3-piece timing set, purchased earlier this year.   Is this picture something, or, nothing?   I have the timing cover off and my crank is perfectly TDC and the keyed gear's locating mark is dead on 12 o'clock.   The cam gear locating mark is also at 12 o'clock. Now, I'm not an expert, but all the install guides say the two locating marks should meet and be perfectly aligned when installing a timing set. The mark on the crank should be dead on 12:00 and the cam gear's mark should be dead on 6:00, and both marks should be perfectly vertically aligned.   I believe the timing gear is keyed or has a dowel that ensures it can only be installed on the cam in one position, so I have to believe the cam is out of phase somehow. At the very least, with a triangular bolt pattern, it can only be installed in one of 3 different positions.   Before I pulled the front cover, the truck was running alright, no service engine soon lights except an occasional P0172 / rich condition. Timing -16 timing at idle (should be +16), and total -35% fuel trim, two conditions I haven't been able to figure out.   In related news, my injector tested pretty well, wasn't leaking, but I had it rebuilt anyway, and it's on it's way back to me.         Along with this discovery, the good and bad:   Good: The oil pan seal appears undamaged.   Bad: -The timing cover has been reused, and the positioning dowels have been broken. That could explain some of the leaking. -Some kind of white paste or grease was used to try to seal the oil pan seal and timing cover (since wiped off..). -Then, someone globbed silicone all over the front of the cover and also buried the ckp sensor in it. But, they didn't put any inside the cover or use RTV to try to seal the oil pan seal with the timing cover (good).
    • The guy that owns K&P filters last I checked in with him has over 300,000 miles on his Dodge base Hemi using his own 35 micron absolute stainless mesh filter from its first oil change.    The GM study I've posted a dozen times shows the relationship in engine life based in multiples of base units, not miles or years. That is the base unit is the number of miles the motor ran using the reference filter efficiency.    The above two paragraphs dismantle anecdotal arguments IF one changes oil often enough to prevent particle formation and the motor is in otherwise good shape. That is not full of silica (no air filter) or suffering a metallurgical issue that is not part of the lubrication discussion. Poor heat treat in example.   Data from UOA's I've reviewed from more than a few engines can show remarkably broad variations in oil cleanliness using the exact same filter over the course of an engines life.     Lastly there is the common sense of it. Wear debris WILL circulate the engine BEFORE it ever sees a filter in route to that filter and WILL harm the pump which NEVER sees filtered oil.    Alpha question then becomes, given the facts, how long do you believe is a reasonable service life from a vehicle you are certain you will not pass down? That is the junk yard will be it's resting place when you're done with it? (the moral issue most don't care about).    Omega question is then how diligent are you prepared to be in general mechanical, air & oil maintenance? Preventing particulates and keeping them sufficiently dilute; preventing the precursors from generation, amalgamation and precipitation.    If I get a good look at the engine bay of a vehicle I have a fair idea of the owners commitment to the inside of the power train. That 30 micron WIX is still more efficient than a sieve.                 
    • It also depends on what criteria someone is using for “best” when talking filters.  Are we going off best efficiency?   Best quality/QC?  Etc. because the two may not mutually exclusive.  
  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...