Jump to content

New here.... considering a switch from Ford F-350 to GMC 3500

gascantx
 Share

Recommended Posts

Jason Voorhees New Member

Jason Voorhees

Posted
Posted
On 8/29/2023 at 9:02 AM, gascantx said:

 

Reliability is definitely important.  However, my desire and view point on this topic is rooted in critical operational monitoring.  As I said, I tow heavy and I while I don't abuse my trucks, I work them hard especially when we tow through the mountains and in the Texas heat.   Knowing exact values of temperature and other sensors allow operators who pay close attention to spot small problems before they become big problems.   

 

My main reason for ditching Ford is a reliability issue... 

 

Note: I don't want to turn this into a Ford Bashing thread but I will share my story....

 

My 2011 Super Duty was one of the very first trucks to have the CP4 High Pressure Fuel pump failure.  Once replaced that truck ran like a rock until I traded it in 2017 for my 2017 (current) Super Duty.  I just assumed I had a fluke.  Well my 2017 had a CP4 failure 3 weeks ago.  Sigh!!!   OMG and it has been a nightmare.  Ford tried hard to deny the extended warranty claim but my truck is well maintained (never ran it out of fuel, never had def or water in the fuel tank, always changed filters on schedule, etc..).  They finally approved after pictures proved to them there was no rust in the high pressure fuel system.   Now we are in parts limbo.   The parts all backordered with no availability date supplied....  It could be months.   Summer and fall travel has been canceled so this has impacted myself and my family.   If you do your research on the Bosch CP4, it is inherently a bad design.  Ford, GM, Dodge/Cummings have all used it.   GM finally went totally away from Bosh in 2017. (Great decision IMO)  Cummings used it for two years and then ditched it.   Ford - in its infinite wisdom - has used it from 2011 and continues to do so.   It is the achilles heel of the 6.7 PowerStroke.  Many people put 100's of thousands of miles on Super Duty's and never experience but I have had it hit me twice now.  Hence my desire to learn and figure out my transition to GM.   I can't bring myself to purchase a Dodge / RAM especially with the latest JD Power Initial Quality results which puts Dodge/RAM at the VERY bottom of the list.  (Cummings engine is fine - it is the rest of the truck and systems that are the problem).   

 

Chrysler products are just not what they used to be. Ram and it’s junk 5.7L Hemi engine plus the 2500 and 3500 frames are made of glass. You’ll hardly ever see an ambulance or a tow truck that is a Ram truck and there’s a very good reason for that. One conversion company outright refuses to convert Ram trucks into tow trucks because of the weak frames. You’ve made a fantastic choice by staying away from Ram trucks. My best friend was a field medic and they used the Ford 250 trucks as their ambulances and they also had the fuel pump failure but it was on the gasoline engine, not diesel. I believe that it happened to 2 of their trucks in the fleet and it happened in a mountain pass in British Columbia, which was as you can imagine, an inconvenience. It happened under load going up a mountain so pieces of the fuel pump ended up getting into the fuel system which caused some damage and it was an extremely expensive repair. I can’t remember if it was covered under warranty or not but I’m sure there’s a lot of these stories. That’s too bad because I like the Ford trucks. I’m a plumber and the best company vehicle I ever drove was the E-Series Ford E-350 van. It was an ex-law enforcement vehicle but it was a very solid vehicle, it felt great like I was driving a tank. The engine was a Triton V10. The gas mileage was ok for the engine size but in the 3 years I drove it I never had an issue with it and I put close to 100K Kms on it. I liked it so much that I went out and bought a P71 Crown Victoria. I hadn’t owned a Ford since the 90s when I had a 1979 Ford Mustang with a straight 6. It was an awful car. Any way, good luck with your GM. I drive a 2015 GMC Sierra myself. 249k kms and no issues. 

  • Replies 34
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

kf9yr
kf9yr

2.  You will need a Banks iDash or similar to get the turbo boost, they are coming out with a mount that attaches to the A-pillar mounting bolt.      I kept the iDash from my 2020 Sierra 250

asilverblazer
asilverblazer

The Ford vs. Chevrolet debate is akin to the Apple vs. Android one.   At this point you can't really say one is significantly superior to the other, but they are different.    The

gascantx
gascantx

Hello GMCers....   I am a longtime Ford guy considering switching from a F-350 Powerstroke to the GMC 3500 Duramax.   With that said....   I am here to learn and ask some questions from you

Posted Images

nitro882 Enthusiast

nitro882

Posted
Posted
On 9/17/2023 at 1:01 PM, Jason Voorhees said:

Chrysler products are just not what they used to be. Ram and it’s junk 5.7L Hemi engine plus the 2500 and 3500 frames are made of glass. You’ll hardly ever see an ambulance or a tow truck that is a Ram truck and there’s a very good reason for that. One conversion company outright refuses to convert Ram trucks into tow trucks because of the weak frames. You’ve made a fantastic choice by staying away from Ram trucks. My best friend was a field medic and they used the Ford 250 trucks as their ambulances and they also had the fuel pump failure but it was on the gasoline engine, not diesel. I believe that it happened to 2 of their trucks in the fleet and it happened in a mountain pass in British Columbia, which was as you can imagine, an inconvenience. It happened under load going up a mountain so pieces of the fuel pump ended up getting into the fuel system which caused some damage and it was an extremely expensive repair. I can’t remember if it was covered under warranty or not but I’m sure there’s a lot of these stories. That’s too bad because I like the Ford trucks. I’m a plumber and the best company vehicle I ever drove was the E-Series Ford E-350 van. It was an ex-law enforcement vehicle but it was a very solid vehicle, it felt great like I was driving a tank. The engine was a Triton V10. The gas mileage was ok for the engine size but in the 3 years I drove it I never had an issue with it and I put close to 100K Kms on it. I liked it so much that I went out and bought a P71 Crown Victoria. I hadn’t owned a Ford since the 90s when I had a 1979 Ford Mustang with a straight 6. It was an awful car. Any way, good luck with your GM. I drive a 2015 GMC Sierra myself. 249k kms and no issues. 

 

I'm guessing your in Canada?  I find the commentary on the RAM to be interesting down here where i live in Florida we have lots of tow trucks built on RAM 5500 chassis, they are quite common. It also seems like in the states the RAM is the most popular truck for hotshot truckers who do massive miles with heavy trailers in tow.

the wanderer Enthusiast

the wanderer

Posted
Posted
10 hours ago, nitro882 said:

 

I'm guessing your in Canada?  I find the commentary on the RAM to be interesting down here where i live in Florida we have lots of tow trucks built on RAM 5500 chassis, they are quite common. It also seems like in the states the RAM is the most popular truck for hotshot truckers who do massive miles with heavy trailers in tow.

 

His post isn't true in my part of Canada either lol. Parks are full of heavy duty rams pullings RVs, I see a ton of older dodges running the cummins though perhaps I see more of them simply because I'm drawn to them myself.

 

Looking at the tone of his post should be a first clue to ignore it and move on. Truck buyers are the most passionate and brand loyal and some buyers are just incapable of rational criticism.

Dunn Senior Enthusiast

Dunn

Posted
Posted
On 9/19/2023 at 6:15 AM, the wanderer said:

 

His post isn't true in my part of Canada either lol. Parks are full of heavy duty rams pullings RVs, I see a ton of older dodges running the cummins though perhaps I see more of them simply because I'm drawn to them myself.

 

Looking at the tone of his post should be a first clue to ignore it and move on. Truck buyers are the most passionate and brand loyal and some buyers are just incapable of rational criticism.

Very true...

 

I bought a Ram as loyal GM dude and hardest thing I think ever  was to sign for a different brand of truck.....just browsing and convincing yourself us alot different than actually signing papers for one🤣.....

 

Things I liked and things I didnt...didnt last lone sold it after 6 months....not sure I would buy another....GM does all the important stuff  correct (for me) and they make best looking truck as well......

 

We have a ton of RAM tow trucks, fire trucks, city trucks, etc down here in California

Pryme Senior Enthusiast

Pryme

Posted
Posted

I like the simple look of the ram hd but I won’t buy a made in Mexico truck so when I was shopping for a truck it was down to the 2500 gm or F250. I didn’t really want to experience death wobble or really care to have a solid front axle so it was down to gm. My first new gm in my life but I’ve had plenty of used models. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Forum Statistics

    250.5k
    Total Topics
    2.7m
    Total Posts

  • Member Statistics

    342,914
    Total Members
    8,960
    Most Online
    AidenVorpagel
    Newest Member
    AidenVorpagel
    Joined

  • Who's Online   2 Members, 0 Anonymous, 1,290 Guests (See full list)

  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • jake111
      Gasser Subforum Has Been Quiet - - So, Regenerative Braking and Using L10

      By jake111 · Posted

      Thanks newdude!  By the time manual selection is needed, I'm probably too much of a control-freak to depend on the transmission sensing braking to activate automatic downshifting.  I would be anticipating the situation and already be manually downshifting.   This truck replaced a 2004.5 LLY diesel with the Allison 5-speed.  Putting it in T/H made noticeable differences (when the torque converter locked, upshift points, downshift behavior).  On this 2024 gasser with the 10L1000 I haven't been able to detect much, if any, difference.  Ok, I can never tell now when the torque converter locks up.  But I also don't notice differences in shifting.  For downhills, I've probably already manually downshifted by then anyway.  Since it's also more awkward (than the 2004.5) to engage/disengage I don't even bother.  Or maybe it doesn't really matter with just a 3k lb. camper in the bed?   Thanks also for the list of reasons the charging system might select various voltages.  However, what I am seeing doesn't fall into any of those categories.  It very definitely, and very consistently, rises after coasting/braking.  Maybe not immediately, but not very long after coasting/braking.  Very consistently drops voltage when no longer coasting/braking.  It might also be interacting with the camper battery charging (I might disconnect the camper and see if it changes the charging behavior).  I also need to recheck turning on headlights for when I want to force it to charge the camper.   Another JR, in June I converted the camper to LiFePO4.  Since it's not a good idea to try to charge lithiums directly using truck, I installed a Victron Orion XS DC-DC charger (which BTW is AMAZING!!).  Being cheap, I only had to buy that one item (besides the battery, of course) to do the conversion.  The camper OEM 120v battery charger (only 19 years old and works perfectly) and the truck feed the input to the DC-DC charger (not at the same time).  But I didn't want the camper charger feeding back to the truck so I kept the old separator.  I considered replacing the separator with a 30amp diode but that means more work and might add another 1/2 volt drop.  One thing that surprised me was the voltage drop over the long 10awg wire run, so I can only charge smoothly at 8 amps (because the DC-DC charger is completely configurable).  Another reason I don't want an added voltage drop with the diode.  I might also be a little lazy but all this work is being done under the sink with a small cabinet opening.    
    • davester
      cam upgrade in CA

      By davester · Posted

      apparently CA smog is (or at least was)  checking that the vehicle is using the oem and/or a ca smog approved tune, so I expect you'll fail inspection doing it.
    • davester
      Possible lifter tick after DOD delete

      By davester · Posted

      yes, leaking exhaust will mess up o2 sensor readings, which in turn messes up fuel trims.
    • Grumpy Bear
      Sugar Bears 2015 GMC Terrain SLE-2 2.4 AWD

      By Grumpy Bear · Posted

      286,740 Mile Services   8/6/2026   New AC Compressor. Refrigerant oil and dye, evacuate and charge system.  New exhaust system from cat back.  New Iridium plugs plus replace #3 coil Repair/rewire headlamp wiring (passenger side) and replace all forward bulbs. Polish lenses of both assemblies.  Pull rear rotors, clean and adjust parking assembly. Inspect, clean and grease front calipers. Check pads and shoes.  4 wheel power bleed of brake system. Dot 4 Reset idle speed 50 rpm higher New Serpentine belt.    Will need new pads in the rear in about 5K more miles.    Tax Title and License out the door just short of a grand.    AC clutch had bitten the dust. 1 year warranty on the pick and save replacement. Thing will make a Polar Bear cry Uncle.  He spent quite some time on the wiring. It was in the harness and he does nothing half. I got off cheap. I have considerable more light down the road. Sylvania Silver Star replacements.  Gas seal between the porcelain and shell of plug #3 was blown, cooked the coil. That was the cold miss.  Love the new exhaust. I can sneak into the neighborhood again.  Nice to have a working parking brake again. Belle Tire never got it done. That was disappointing.    This was one of her bigger bills and still way cheaper than a payment even given the oil consumption. This thing cost me under a hundred a month in repairs and normal routine costs. What is my incentive to replace it? 🤔           
    • AidenVorpagel
      cam upgrade in CA

      By AidenVorpagel · Posted

      hello I recently bought a 2012 gmc 1500 with a 5.3 and have a AFM disabler on it I'm interested in doing a cam but I'm worried if I remove the AFM system I will fail smog does anyone have info if they are able to detect that or a work around to it (not talking about hot smogging) please let me know thank you  

  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...