Jump to content

Does Onstar Know If You've Swapped Ecm's?

eracer

Recommended Posts

eracer Enthusiast

eracer

Posted
Posted

I have a friend who is contemplating getting a blank ECM for his 2009 Sierra 1500 5.3L (let's just say my friend knows somebody who can get him this "swap-only" GM part...)

 

He is considering sending it to a tuner, then putting it in his truck, keeping the stock ECM in case he needs to take the truck in for service.

 

His concern is about the Big Brother called OnStar. He knows that OnStar communicates with the ECM, and routinely transmits DTC info to the Government Motors servers. The question is:

 

Will putting a new ECM in be detected by the OnStar system? Does the ECM have a serial number that is uploaded? Or is the VIN (which is flashed into the tuned ECM) the only identifier that OnStar uses?

 

My friend thanks you in advance.

VMax2007 Senior Enthusiast

VMax2007

Posted
Posted

I get Onstar diagnostic notifications every month with no issues and I have swapped my ECM several times. When I had my Edge Evo pile of crap handheld, the Onstar diagnostics got hosed up, but since I dumped that POS and got a real tune, it has been working fine and "Big Brother" has not picked on me at all. :cheers:

txab Senior Enthusiast

txab

Posted
Posted
No onstar will not know. The friend is you isn't it :cheers:
No, nyet, nein, non, nope...uhn-uhn. Not me at all....

 

 

Yeah, sure. :D

eracer Enthusiast

eracer

Posted
  • Author
Posted
No onstar will not know. The friend is you isn't it :lol:
No, nyet, nein, non, nope...uhn-uhn. Not me at all....

 

 

Yeah, sure. :D

 

 

Here's what I've learned. (Learn from my mistake....)

 

If you install a new ECM tuned with different tables, and you get a "Check Engine" light, and you push the little blue "OnStar" button and ask them to diagnose the light...

 

...you're screwed. You have just transmitted checksums that show them (and GM) that you either swapped the ECM out or got the OEM module flashed with new tables.

 

So the answer to my question is, "YES, ONSTAR KNOWS WHEN YOU'VE INSTALLED A NEW ECM..."

 

Now, when (my friend) takes his truck in for powertrain warranty work, the dealer will be able to laugh in (his) face...

 

Moral of the story (one I wished I'd known...) is that you should call OnStar and opt out of the diagnostic evaluation program. They can't (legally) download your ECM data then. Whether they still will is anyone's guess...

brims Senior Enthusiast

brims

Posted
Posted
Here's what I've learned. (Learn from my mistake....)

 

If you install a new ECM tuned with different tables, and you get a "Check Engine" light, and you push the little blue "OnStar" button and ask them to diagnose the light...

 

...you're screwed. You have just transmitted checksums that show them (and GM) that you either swapped the ECM out or got the OEM module flashed with new tables.

 

So the answer to my question is, "YES, ONSTAR KNOWS WHEN YOU'VE INSTALLED A NEW ECM..."

 

Now, when (my friend) takes his truck in for powertrain warranty work, the dealer will be able to laugh in (his) face...

 

Moral of the story (one I wished I'd known...) is that you should call OnStar and opt out of the diagnostic evaluation program. They can't (legally) download your ECM data then. Whether they still will is anyone's guess...

 

 

I solved this whole issue by pulling the fuse for OnStar and when I get around to it, the module will be doing the same thing that the XM module is doing, sitting on the shelf. Well, technically the XM module is still sitting in the back of the truck and has been for 4 or 5 months because I've been too lazy to take it in.

stlavsa Senior Enthusiast

stlavsa

Posted
Posted
Here's what I've learned. (Learn from my mistake....)

 

If you install a new ECM tuned with different tables, and you get a "Check Engine" light, and you push the little blue "OnStar" button and ask them to diagnose the light...

 

...you're screwed. You have just transmitted checksums that show them (and GM) that you either swapped the ECM out or got the OEM module flashed with new tables.

 

So the answer to my question is, "YES, ONSTAR KNOWS WHEN YOU'VE INSTALLED A NEW ECM..."

 

Now, when (my friend) takes his truck in for powertrain warranty work, the dealer will be able to laugh in (his) face...

 

Moral of the story (one I wished I'd known...) is that you should call OnStar and opt out of the diagnostic evaluation program. They can't (legally) download your ECM data then. Whether they still will is anyone's guess...

 

 

I solved this whole issue by pulling the fuse for OnStar and when I get around to it, the module will be doing the same thing that the XM module is doing, sitting on the shelf. Well, technically the XM module is still sitting in the back of the truck and has been for 4 or 5 months because I've been too lazy to take it in.

 

 

 

I agree hell with onstar but XM man ur crazy i love it

brims Senior Enthusiast

brims

Posted
Posted
I agree hell with onstar but XM man ur crazy i love it

 

I like metal and XM's metal stations are pretty soft, Metallica is typically their hardest stuff. And I don't want to screw with paying some company to listen to commercials in a "commercial free" radio. "but we have over 50 channels without commercials" "and you have 150 channels, 2/3 of your channels have plenty of commercials" That's pretty much how the conversation started with the XM rep. All the commercial free stations are Britney Spears and nSync and whoever the hell else people are listening to now-a-days.

  • 1 month later...
Nytemare Senior Enthusiast

Nytemare

Posted
Posted
I agree hell with onstar but XM man ur crazy i love it

 

I like metal and XM's metal stations are pretty soft, Metallica is typically their hardest stuff. And I don't want to screw with paying some company to listen to commercials in a "commercial free" radio. "but we have over 50 channels without commercials" "and you have 150 channels, 2/3 of your channels have plenty of commercials" That's pretty much how the conversation started with the XM rep. All the commercial free stations are Britney Spears and nSync and whoever the hell else people are listening to now-a-days.

 

 

Totally aggree brims....I'm a metal head too....and while Metallica is cool and all.....its just not enough....so screw the XM/Sirius iPod it is. That way you can listen to commercial free music and play any song you want to....oh and other than the cost of the iPod...its free.

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • SoCal Angler
      OEM Trailer Hitch Receiver - Impact tightened by shop

      By SoCal Angler · Posted

      After my recent rear end bumper damage, body shop has made the repairs and included a new OEM receiver hitch.  I started thinking about how it was tightened...to specs or by hand or ??.  I called the body shop and asked and they said it was tightened by an impact gun.  I said I wanted it tightened to OEM specs.  They said no problem, bring it to shop today and they will torque to specs, which they say is 74 ft/lbs.   A couple of questions,,,,   1.  Should new bolts have been used?  If so, how many are there (bill shows one and four (I assume different areas of receiver).   2.,  Since they torqued with impact gun and now are going to probably loosen and then torque to spces, will that damage/stretch the bolts?   3.  If old bolts were reused (truck has 9000 miles), is that a problem?   4.  Any other things iI may have missed with regard to receiver replacement?   Thanks!
    • newdude
      Defective Brake Pad Wear Sensor?

      By newdude · Posted

      Is this supposed to be in English?  "close to 100 fake, new brake pads sign on the dash board"     Pull the wheels off.  Check the brake pad thickness.  Check the sensors out.  You could have good pads and the sensors aren't in to the worn out position, but have an electrical fault with the sensor or the plug wiring to the sensor.   
    • newdude
      Trans Cooler Thermostat Valve Body Seals - 2022 10L80

      By newdude · Posted

      Gas or diesel???????????   You did not indicate.  Your topic just says "2022 10L80".      
    • Donstar
      Navigating senior years.

      By Donstar · Posted

      Tomorrow I go in for my third joint replacement in jus a little over a year year!  I am not worried about the surgery but I am a little annoyed about going through the recovery process again!  I keep my frustrations to myself as I do appreciate that I am truly lucky.  Knee, hip, and shoulder replacements are routine, safe and improve mobility.  The next couple of days will be slow but every day following will see steady improvement in my mobility.  
    • Grumpy Bear
      OCI, not when but why?

      By Grumpy Bear · Posted

      Practical Application ISO 4406   I think this oil cleanliness thing is going to boil down to ones personal resolve. The information is there but applying it I believe will test your commitment to the machine. Implementation would involve building or buying a prefilter or purchase of an "ISOCLEAN" oil. Then installing a single digit micron bypass system. A good deal of testing and about 99.9% of you are saying at that point....yea.....not my cuppa tea. So what can you do?    You already did the first step. Get educated and leave the bias at the door. Be aware of the its, cleanliness, importance.    Do your own work if you can. Keep the equipment clean. Not just your funnel but the engine bay. Use sealed containers. Think it through.    I believe you will find, as I did, that the tightest absolute full flow filters (Beta 200) will be around 20 micron. That will yield on average a Beta 75 of 10-15 micron. They are few in number by brand and price point. Loose filters are a dime a dozen and even the best brands have lines of loose filters. Some cleverly marketed as "Extended Service". Others will market flow over efficiency. But I think the take away once informed is that the extra cost of the best offered is a bargain. There are cheaper filters with good efficiency that are equal in performance to niche brands with big prices. Your Quick Lube is about a 40 micron unit. This is where your dealer is a plus. the AC-Delco filter is a good step up from those places. Even better if you specify the UPF line.    Be skeptical of marketing. Buying an oil that is made from GTL advertised as the cleanest base oil is using a truth to support a lie. While GTL's are made from debris free gas the processing equipment and post handling is just like any other oil. It also ignores the fact that PAO's and Esters are also gas in origin. Any private prescreening testing you would do, and some have done, would yield a result only good for the batch you tested. AMSOIL and Schaeffer's have built a reputation for paying attention to this detail.    Context. Cold starts account for at least 75%, or more, of an engines wear. But of the remaining 25% ish, over 80% is caused by particle count. Now where do we find high milage motors that use this type of information efficiently? OTR trucking!      Now, anyone want to build a prefilter or off line cleaning system anyway?   

  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...