Jump to content

Is it when or if on lifter failure?

spikesputnik
 Share

Recommended Posts

spikesputnik Enthusiast

spikesputnik

Posted
Posted (edited)

Haven been here much in recent years but I still have my 09, though it’s been relegated to farm/beater so to speak.  But still a valuable member of the family and just rolled over to 100k miles. At less than 5 k miles I had Blackbear delete AFM and do a very mild tune, as well as to the tranny ECU.  I’ve been very good about oil/filter changes at around 50% on the OLM. A few oil analysis came back fine every time.  May have used 1/2 qt last change. No engine or trans problems despite pulling 4000# boat at highway to freeway speeds for 10-15k miles over a few years I’d guess. Got a dedicated better puller in 2018 and 2022 ….from the dark side 😉


Anyways, so I’m jump back on here and refresh myself with the goings on with these trucks and see a lot of talk about lifter failures…. 

Question on consensus- is it just a matter of time till my lifters fail? Anyone take a guess as to a percentage of these 5.3 AFM  that will despite short interval high quality oil changes?  
 

As I understand it, neglect could make it more likely with clogged screens and low pressures.  But it also seems there is a degree of randomness (suboptimal lifter design) to the problem?

I’ve heard of crazy expensive repairs, and replacing the lifters prophylactically might not make financial sense.  I’d like to keep this truck for hauling stuff as well as hauling the dog, but don’t necessarily want to hang onto a grenade. 
 

Edited by spikesputnik
shakenfake Senior Enthusiast

shakenfake

Posted
Posted

Oh brother here we go again....

 

 

Personally I would delete it ASAP. It is probably less than 10% of vehicles that have lifter issues though.

spikesputnik Enthusiast

spikesputnik

Posted
  • Author
Posted
8 minutes ago, shakenfake said:

Oh brother here we go again....

 

 

Personally I would delete it ASAP. It is probably less than 10% of vehicles that have lifter issues though.

Well, it was deleted 95k miles ago…

But the percentage is encouraging. 👍🏻

shakenfake Senior Enthusiast

shakenfake

Posted
Posted

But seriously I would consider deleting it. It is not a very difficult job to do at home in the garage if you have the space for it.

nqabigt Enthusiast

nqabigt

Posted
Posted

08 here 166+++ miles 

range device since 60k

also 1/2 quart between changes

I wouldnt worry about it, 

spikesputnik Enthusiast

spikesputnik

Posted
  • Author
Posted
10 hours ago, shakenfake said:

But seriously I would consider deleting it. It is not a very difficult job to do at home in the garage if you have the space for it.

LOL I have lots of space, but not that much bravery or skills- dirt bike top ends is about as far as I’d go!

But I do have a shade tree type guys with the skills. 

diyer2 Senior Enthusiast

diyer2

Posted
Posted

I think your more frequent oil changes are a huge factor and your worrying about something that may not happen. Now is not the time to be buying any vehicle. 

  • Thanks 1
spikesputnik Enthusiast

spikesputnik

Posted
  • Author
Posted
14 minutes ago, diyer2 said:

I think your more frequent oil changes are a huge factor and your worrying about something that may not happen. Now is not the time to be buying any vehicle. 

True that.  It took me around 4 months to get my ordered truck.  Yea, I’ll probably just keep an ear on it for now. 

  • Like 1
Grumpy Bear Senior Enthusiast

Grumpy Bear

Posted
Posted

Let's recap here:

 

  • 100K miles of trouble free service.
  • The AFM is tuned out.
  • You do approx. 3500 mile OCI's.

 

Your way past the point were a defect in metallurgy (heat treat) would be an issue EVER. 

Knowing that most lifter failures (99% of the >1% that fail) happen as the result of a mistimed switching event (oil foaming or low oil pressure) and yours NEVER EVER switch....

Your OCI length keeps lifter guides happy....

🤔

 

What is your concern again? :dunno:

 

Give it a sharp and complete tune up (including trans, diffs, UOA) , keep doing what you do and drive it another 10 to 15 years. 

 

They sky is not falling......😬

 

And if you still can't sleep drop it off at my place......

I'll take that grenade off your hands, for free naturally, me taking all that risk. :crackup:

 

  

  • Thanks 1
shakenfake Senior Enthusiast

shakenfake

Posted
Posted (edited)

What diyer2 and grumpy said are true no need to worry about something that most likely will never happen to you :)

BUT I hear a lot of this stuff saying how frequent oil changes are why the lifters never fail and that is a laughable claim imo. The K2XX with AFM that my father owned got it's oil changed whenever the truck's oil light popped on, and we all know that thing comes on when it feels like it, and that truck lasted over 150k miles and went on many a trip with no issues. I know some guys who change it religiously at 3.5k-5k and they still had failures.

 

I just think it is mostly random.:fingersx:

Edited by shakenfake
KARNUT Senior Enthusiast

KARNUT

Posted
Posted
39 minutes ago, shakenfake said:

What diyer2 and grumpy said are true no need to worry about something that most likely will never happen to you :)

BUT I hear a lot of this stuff saying how frequent oil changes are why the lifters never fail and that is a laughable claim imo. The K2XX with AFM that my father owned got it's oil changed whenever the truck's oil light popped on, and we all know that thing comes on when it feels like it, and that truck lasted over 150k miles and went on many a trip with no issues. I know some guys who change it religiously at 3.5k-5k and they still had failures.

 

I just think it is mostly random.:fingersx:

I ask a service writer when my vehicle was approaching 120K miles if there was any reasonable time frame to replace certain parts. I referring to wear parts such as starter, alternator, wheel  bearings things that could ruin a trip, especially now. Of course certain things effect that life, highway miles or town driving. With the exception of my past collector vehicles 120K miles was the max in mileage for me or 5 years.  They were little help. 

spikesputnik Enthusiast

spikesputnik

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Grumpy Bear said:

Let's recap here:

 

  • 100K miles of trouble free service.
  • The AFM is tuned out.
  • You do approx. 3500 mile OCI's.

 

Your way past the point were a defect in metallurgy (heat treat) would be an issue EVER. 

Knowing that most lifter failures (99% of the >1% that fail) happen as the result of a mistimed switching event (oil foaming or low oil pressure) and yours NEVER EVER switch....

Your OCI length keeps lifter guides happy....

🤔

 

What is your concern again? :dunno:

 

Give it a sharp and complete tune up (including trans, diffs, UOA) , keep doing what you do and drive it another 10 to 15 years. 

 

They sky is not falling......😬

 

And if you still can't sleep drop it off at my place......

I'll take that grenade off your hands, for free naturally, me taking all that risk. :crackup:

 

  

Thanks for the thorough recap, Grumpy.  What I didn’t know was that metallurgy related failure would be unlikely at this juncture, though it kinda makes sense.  
I’ll be sampling for a UOA before running in for a bit my occasional pre-change 1/2 quart MM oil- another part of my routine.   I know the MM may be controversial or snake oil, but I like the smell!  My thinking is it may get goo and boogers in solution to be filtered out and dumped.  Well, probably not goo and boogers, but I have no idea what be accumulating there on the inside. 

Edited by spikesputnik
  • Haha 1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • Atlas
      AC diagnostic on a neo-classic Camaro

      By Atlas · Posted

      tldr; Shade tree mechanic stumped by variable displacement AC compressor.   Not Silverado related, but for my 2000 Camaro SS. I've never really used the AC since acquiring the car a good handful of years ago. I plan to take it on a trip this summer so I wanted to make sure the AC was in good shape. On an 73 degree day in the shop with the car idling I set the AC on "Max", temp set to cold, and fan on hi. The compressor turned on and air turned nice and cold.   I let it run for several minutes but noticed the compressor never cycled off. The engine was up to temperature enough that it began cycling the cooling fans on high. I had a set of manifold gauges hooked up and it was consistently at about 25 psi on the low side and between 200 and 225 psi (warm engine) on the high side. Per temperature charts, the low side is low (should be 30-35) and the high side is a little high (up to 170 per chart). I read the low pressure as potentially being under-charged underscored by a continually running compressor This was also underscored by temp readings of mid-20 degrees at the vents. Not just cold, freezing cold. Switching off the AC but leaving the HVAC fan on high produced a deluge of condensation underneath the vehicle. I was getting ice buildup on the evap core most likely.   The low reading (25psi) concerned me that the compressor wasn't switching off so I swapped out the pressure switch. No change in behavior, still ran constantly.   The AC clutch works fine as it engages/disengages with the HVAC switch on command. The compressor relay is good as I swapped it with two different known good relays just to be sure. Having eliminated that, and the pressure switch, I added refrigerant, thinking the constant run and low "low" pressure were signs of a slight undercharge. Makes sense, the car is 26 years old and it doesn't appear the AC system has ever been touched.   Adding some R134a didn't meaningfully change the low side pressure. And that's when a lightbulb flashed upstairs. While I consider the car "old", it's possibly "new" enough to have a variable displacement compressor. Did some reading and sure enough. Dangit. I don't work on these for this reason.   Adding refrigerant means the compressor will just compensate and won't really change pressures until it's severely overcharged or undercharged. But at least I wasn't getting ice/frost anymore, but instead high 30 degree temps out of the vents. That's more normal, but with variable displacement now I have no idea where my charge level is at. It's probably overcharged now. The high side even with the engine radiating serious heat was never really over about 225.   The static pressure at room temperature is dead on, before and after the charge. Both high/low equalize after some rest.   I'm thinking I'll need to take it to a shop. I want the proper charge level so I'm not working the compressor too hard. The only way to get an accurate charge is to evacuate and then re-charge with the exact amount specified for the system -- at least that's what I'm reading.   Anyone here with modern automotive AC knowledge?  
    • Byrds8
      Ac not keeping up

      By Byrds8 · Posted

      Mine is in the shop for the AC now. While it did get cold after a bit, it would take a while to even start to cool the air at all. Turns out the compressor was bad and cycling. 
    • KARNUT
      Ac not keeping up

      By KARNUT · Posted

      I call B.S. when I first moved to Texas my first house would only cool to 80 with the Texas heat. The AC tech said it was normal at 100 degrees outside. I remodeled the house put in a new AC. I could hang meat. My cars may need recirculating to start. Once moving it switches to regular AC and I could hang meat. Living in Texas no one would put up with only 20 degrees difference. 
    • Silverado4x4
      Ac not keeping up

      By Silverado4x4 · Posted

      AC in home or auto only cool down 15-25 degrees from outside temp, but what will help is to put the ac in recirc mode this will recirc the Inside cabin air rather then trying to cool down the outside hot air, I always have mine in recirc mode.
    • Mrob7
      1965 GMC 1000 series floor shifter

      By Mrob7 · Posted

      Found the fix for this.  Untightan the bolt just below top linkage on the steering column, turn assembly left to reduce space between the two linkage rods at the steering column, tighten bolt.  Made a big improvement.

  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...