Jump to content

US vs Mexico Build Quality

OkieMedic
 Share

Recommended Posts

wizard4878 Enthusiast

wizard4878

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, JimCost2014 said:

Wonder if there is someone in Japan right now complaining about the build quality of his Accord that was built in Ohio?

 

Riding Donkeys to work actually might be a good marketing plan, they do get great mileage with pretty low emissions….

that emissions thing might depend on what you feed them...

  • Haha 2
  • Replies 63
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

diyer2
diyer2

I think the build location is a non factor. It's the luck of the draw. This is true with every product we buy IMO. You get a good one or you don't.

Donstar
Donstar

As previously mentioned, this question has come up earlier.  It provides an opportunity for personal politics and prejudice to be expressed.  You may even read some attempts to make up "factoids" to s

OnTheReel
OnTheReel

Nobody is going to be blown away by the build quality of these trucks from either plant, let’s be real here. ?   Personally, I think the Mexican-made loaner I had was put together a bit better 

Posted Images

wizard4878 Enthusiast

wizard4878

Posted
Posted

IMO  you should go find and drive one of each and then decided for yourself because in the end you have to pay for it and, as you can already see,  your going to get a million different opinions here

fatwhiteboy Enthusiast

fatwhiteboy

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, JimCost2014 said:

Just kind of catching the end of this "debate", so I will ask a serious question:

 

What would I, or someone else be looking for as far as the differences in the trucks?

 

Having worked at a dealership, I never really noticed a huge difference between the trucks built in different places. 

The frame and drivetrain is the same Jim.  Where I saw a huge difference is flush and gap for body parts and interior trim.  Anything done in GA that is operator dependent.  Their paint is not as good as north America simply from lack of maintenance.  Whereever the bed lands it is tightened, no alignment.  They don't care.  Another thing I noticed is you never know if the employee or his wife or his brother will be on the line.  They look away. They just need a body in that spot.  None of the GM engineers from Michigan want to be there and from what I saw they don't want us down there either.  Other car companies that have plants down there make their experienced engineers live there for the life of the program.  FCA finally brought their HD trucks back to Michigan due to terrible quality in Mexico.  But, the labor rate is low so GM makes way more on a truck made in Mexico compared to here.  China is the same way.  Companies eat up to 50% scrap because it is so cheap to make parts there but the failures are huge.  GM is happy to hear folks do not see a difference or care where they are built.  If upper management had their way, nothing would be made here, our labor rates are high compared to many other countries BUT, they will never buy a car or truck.

jlong1984 Enthusiast

jlong1984

Posted
Posted
6 minutes ago, fatwhiteboy said:

FCA finally brought their HD trucks back to Michigan due to terrible quality in Mexico.

No, they didn't. Go look at a 2019 or 2020 RAM HD, every single one still has a VIN starting with 3. When Sergio died, they scrapped the plan to bring them back. 

 

My 2019 Sierra is a Ft. Wayne build, my 16 & 14 Silverados were both Silao made. I don't see much of a difference in fit and finish. My 14 was a vibrator, but I can't blame that on the assembly plant. When I bought my 19 I sought out a U.S. made truck, not because I was unhappy with the quality of the other two, but just because of pride. GM is an American company, and I think they should build as many vehicles here as they can profitably. 

  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1
dane0254 Enthusiast

dane0254

Posted
Posted

I have had two built in Mexico and I ordered another one recently. I was happy with the trucks and did not see any issues with fit, interior or exterior. I get quad cabs so I really don't have a choice. Would I prefer they are all built in the U.S., of course. 

  • Like 1
Moend Enthusiast

Moend

Posted
Posted

I don't think there is a different. Both my 08 and 19 can from Mexico. I had no problem with my 08 and small but very annoying problems with my 19.

 

And the videos that been shared mean nothing. There is always an ugly side. I have worked for a lot of companies and whenever the big wigs come in for a tour we tidy up the place. But it doesn't look tidy every day.

fatwhiteboy Enthusiast

fatwhiteboy

Posted
Posted
On 1/15/2020 at 6:19 PM, jlong1984 said:

No, they didn't. Go look at a 2019 or 2020 RAM HD, every single one still has a VIN starting with 3. When Sergio died, they scrapped the plan to bring them back. 

 

My 2019 Sierra is a Ft. Wayne build, my 16 & 14 Silverados were both Silao made. I don't see much of a difference in fit and finish. My 14 was a vibrator, but I can't blame that on the assembly plant. When I bought my 19 I sought out a U.S. made truck, not because I was unhappy with the quality of the other two, but just because of pride. GM is an American company, and I think they should build as many vehicles here as they can profitably. 

They are supposed to start production of the American version of the truck this month.  I knew a few guys at FCA that strongly admitted that truck is junk due to where it is built.

 

https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2018/jan/18/donald-trump/trump-said-chrysler-leaving-mexico-it-isnt/

ILSilverado Enthusiast

ILSilverado

Posted
Posted

My 2019 was built in Indiana my 2020 in Mexico. The only difference for me was I named the 2020 Carlos!

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
jlong1984 Enthusiast

jlong1984

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, fatwhiteboy said:

They are supposed to start production of the American version of the truck this month.  I knew a few guys at FCA that strongly admitted that truck is junk due to where it is built.

 

https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2018/jan/18/donald-trump/trump-said-chrysler-leaving-mexico-it-isnt/

That is from January 2018, when the former head of FCA, Sergio Marchionne was still alive. He had planned to move assembly of the new 2019 HD pickups to Michigan. That changed after his death in July of the same year, when Mike Manley took over. 

 

Straight from the Fiat-Chrysler website. 

 

Quote

On Feb. 26, 2019, FCA confirmed that the investment announced in 2017 will increase to $1.5 billion and include tooling to produce electrified versions of the Jeep Wagoneer and Grand Wagoneer. As part of the announcement, the Company also confirmed that production of the Ram 1500 Classic will continue. It is expected that 1,400 new jobs will be added. With this announcement, production of the all-new Ram Heavy Duty will continue at its current location in Saltillo, Mexico. (FCA had announced in January 2018 that heavy duty production would move from Saltillo, Mexico, to Warren.)

https://media.fcanorthamerica.com/newsrelease.do?id=343

  • 2 years later...
Samuel Daniels New Member

Samuel Daniels

Posted
Posted

The quality system put in place are at all GM and GMC plants.  There is only one quality system and plenty of cross checking between plants to maintain consistency.  After 40 years in the automotive parts manufacturing business and supplying to GM,  I know 1st hand the difficulty in getting and maintaining their QS certification which is necessary to do business with them.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Peter land Enthusiast

Peter land

Posted
Posted
On 1/14/2020 at 9:04 PM, diyer2 said:

I think the build location is a non factor.

It's the luck of the draw.

This is true with every product we buy IMO.

You get a good one or you don't.

:)

Agreed 100%. 

  • Like 1
  • 4 months later...
codeman11 New Member

codeman11

Posted
Posted (edited)

I have no experience within the factories, but I can chime in and say that the interior quality issues in a made in Mexico GM seems to be true, at least in my case. I have a '22 refresh, Sierra Denali. Interior trim fitment issues, and screws improperly fastened to the point where some of the plastic tabs have cracked / enlarged the holes.

 

That has to do with a worker and proper QC ... sorry but there is some truth to variations in quality when coming from different factories. Morale and average IQ play a role no matter where you go. Perhaps the US factory has more laziness, perhaps it's Mexico - who knows. But where there's a human element, you can't honestly claim things are 100% the same. That's just plain stupidity.

Edited by codeman11
  • Like 1
dieselfan1 Senior Enthusiast

dieselfan1

Posted
Posted

I've had a Mexican 2018 and a Fort Wayne 2018.

The Mexican truck needed the bed realigned and both rear doors were mis aligned.

Paint on the Mexican was sub par IMO.

The ft Wayne 2018 didn't have these issues.

Now I have 2 Ft Wayne 2022 LTDs a high country and an LTZ.  Neither have these issues.

I think the Mexican plant just slaps them together and not much QC going on. I think they have no pride in their work. The Fort Wayne folks do take pride in their work. Fact.

 

gt tangerine Enthusiast

gt tangerine

Posted
Posted

My Mexican refresh AT4 has the best paint I’ve had on a GM truck. My last was a 21 Silao built LT trail boss and the two before that were both Ft Wayne. For what it’s worth I would have rather had a US built truck but I have to admit the refresh I received is extremely well put together. No rattles no bed alignment issues 

Churchill729 Enthusiast

Churchill729

Posted
Posted (edited)

I purchased a 2022 Silverado that was made in Silao. 
 

I’ve been happy with it so far. Quality seems fine to me. 
 

I did find the attached checklist rolled up and wedged in the suspension. Kind of a neat tie in to the worker who assembled it. 

BFDCD591-CBEE-4E72-853D-B9712B1510F9.jpeg

Edited by Churchill729
Typo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • Chuck FB
      MPG at 600 miles

      By Chuck FB · Posted

      I would have to read back to get a better picture in my mind of some of the other comments and what they were using for a driving scenario they based the fuel mileage off of. That is why the fuel mileage conversation is extremely difficult to make fair comparisons from. If I was to be living in town and only driving around town, light to light and some longer stretches that doesn't have a light every block, and the usual stop at a grocery store and the bank and so on and so forth, my fuel mileage even during the summer time would be so bad with my truck I don't even want to know how bad it would be !. Then add in winter time and idling to warm it up to clear the windows and driving through snowy streets etc, large heavy trucks with gas engines have NEVER been worth crap for fuel mileage and why some little pot licker of a car with wheelbarrow tires and a 1300 cc four cylinder non turbo engine was the ticket to using a mere fraction of the fuel over a full size pickup.    By the way my truck has the 34" tires as its a HC but not the BFG KO3 tires ( that was an option for my truck but the sales guy couldn't figure out what the tires actually were so that never got on the order until it was too late to change the truck order ). So what fuel mileage your getting actually sounds good for "town driving" and with my truck when I go to town the fuel mileage keeps increasing as I get closer to town because it takes quite a while to get the driveline oils warmed up ( and why it always shows better fuel mileage on the return trip from town because its already warmed up ) but once I am in town that fuel mileage average just keeps dropping the more I mess around town and then has to recover back to something reasonable again by the time I get home for an over all average.    I'd be curious what your sticker says for the factory weight of your truck, mine is close around that 7700 lb due to the options it has. But anyway the long and short is, vehicle weight, higher rolling resistance heavy tires and a hefty driveline and a relatively large gas engine make for crap fuel mileage in stop and go scenarios, all one can do is drive it easy off the line at each stop and as my dad had said over the years, drive like a raw egg is under your foot and that's the best one can do. Years back with a carbed engine and if the carb was getting a bit out of tune etc as would the ignition system, the fuel mileage on pickups with larger engines was just awful compared to what your getting. We pay the fuel price penalty for driving HD trucks over some little vehicle, that is the reality. 
    • diyer2
      Navigating senior years.

      By diyer2 · Posted

      Speedy recovery.
    • KARNUT
      Slate Electric Truck

      By KARNUT · Posted

      We had two Toyota’s with that engine in the mid 80s. We had 50 gallon fuel tanks, a toolbox full of tools, an air compressor and assorted parts for our equipment. We beat those up and down pipeline ROWs until we started buying diesel trucks. Then they became parts runners and first vehicles for our teenagers first cars. Our shop Forman wrecked them both two years apart when we hired him out of high school as an apprentice. Good thing he’s an excellent mechanic. It took awhile before he could be called a good driver.
    • diyer2
      Gas Prices

      By diyer2 · Posted

      $4.26 85 oct 
    • William Aldrich
      Bent valve in 2025 GMC Canyon Denali - Requires engine swap at 14K miles

      By William Aldrich · Posted

      I have a 2025 GMC Canyon Denali.   On a trip recently the engine failed.  The dealership diagnosed a bent valve and says there is a service bulletin that indicates to 'relace the engine'.  The truck only has about 14K miles and is under warranty.   The failure occurred 5/11/2026.   So far I have worked with GM Customer Assistance and Roadside Assistance.  Evidently no engines are available and nobody will offer a date when a new one will be.   Coming up on two months with no repair or timeline and no loaner from the dealership.   GMC Customer Assistance is 'ghosting' me and keeps closing the cases I've opened with no resolution.   Hoping someone can help me on how to escalate this issue.

  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...