Jump to content

US vs Mexico Build Quality

OkieMedic
 Share

Recommended Posts

wizard4878 Enthusiast

wizard4878

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, JimCost2014 said:

Wonder if there is someone in Japan right now complaining about the build quality of his Accord that was built in Ohio?

 

Riding Donkeys to work actually might be a good marketing plan, they do get great mileage with pretty low emissions….

that emissions thing might depend on what you feed them...

  • Haha 2
  • Replies 63
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Popular Posts

diyer2
diyer2

I think the build location is a non factor. It's the luck of the draw. This is true with every product we buy IMO. You get a good one or you don't.

Donstar
Donstar

As previously mentioned, this question has come up earlier.  It provides an opportunity for personal politics and prejudice to be expressed.  You may even read some attempts to make up "factoids" to s

OnTheReel
OnTheReel

Nobody is going to be blown away by the build quality of these trucks from either plant, let’s be real here. ?   Personally, I think the Mexican-made loaner I had was put together a bit better 

Posted Images

wizard4878 Enthusiast

wizard4878

Posted
Posted

IMO  you should go find and drive one of each and then decided for yourself because in the end you have to pay for it and, as you can already see,  your going to get a million different opinions here

fatwhiteboy Enthusiast

fatwhiteboy

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, JimCost2014 said:

Just kind of catching the end of this "debate", so I will ask a serious question:

 

What would I, or someone else be looking for as far as the differences in the trucks?

 

Having worked at a dealership, I never really noticed a huge difference between the trucks built in different places. 

The frame and drivetrain is the same Jim.  Where I saw a huge difference is flush and gap for body parts and interior trim.  Anything done in GA that is operator dependent.  Their paint is not as good as north America simply from lack of maintenance.  Whereever the bed lands it is tightened, no alignment.  They don't care.  Another thing I noticed is you never know if the employee or his wife or his brother will be on the line.  They look away. They just need a body in that spot.  None of the GM engineers from Michigan want to be there and from what I saw they don't want us down there either.  Other car companies that have plants down there make their experienced engineers live there for the life of the program.  FCA finally brought their HD trucks back to Michigan due to terrible quality in Mexico.  But, the labor rate is low so GM makes way more on a truck made in Mexico compared to here.  China is the same way.  Companies eat up to 50% scrap because it is so cheap to make parts there but the failures are huge.  GM is happy to hear folks do not see a difference or care where they are built.  If upper management had their way, nothing would be made here, our labor rates are high compared to many other countries BUT, they will never buy a car or truck.

jlong1984 Enthusiast

jlong1984

Posted
Posted
6 minutes ago, fatwhiteboy said:

FCA finally brought their HD trucks back to Michigan due to terrible quality in Mexico.

No, they didn't. Go look at a 2019 or 2020 RAM HD, every single one still has a VIN starting with 3. When Sergio died, they scrapped the plan to bring them back. 

 

My 2019 Sierra is a Ft. Wayne build, my 16 & 14 Silverados were both Silao made. I don't see much of a difference in fit and finish. My 14 was a vibrator, but I can't blame that on the assembly plant. When I bought my 19 I sought out a U.S. made truck, not because I was unhappy with the quality of the other two, but just because of pride. GM is an American company, and I think they should build as many vehicles here as they can profitably. 

  • Thanks 1
  • Haha 1
dane0254 Enthusiast

dane0254

Posted
Posted

I have had two built in Mexico and I ordered another one recently. I was happy with the trucks and did not see any issues with fit, interior or exterior. I get quad cabs so I really don't have a choice. Would I prefer they are all built in the U.S., of course. 

  • Like 1
Moend Enthusiast

Moend

Posted
Posted

I don't think there is a different. Both my 08 and 19 can from Mexico. I had no problem with my 08 and small but very annoying problems with my 19.

 

And the videos that been shared mean nothing. There is always an ugly side. I have worked for a lot of companies and whenever the big wigs come in for a tour we tidy up the place. But it doesn't look tidy every day.

fatwhiteboy Enthusiast

fatwhiteboy

Posted
Posted
On 1/15/2020 at 6:19 PM, jlong1984 said:

No, they didn't. Go look at a 2019 or 2020 RAM HD, every single one still has a VIN starting with 3. When Sergio died, they scrapped the plan to bring them back. 

 

My 2019 Sierra is a Ft. Wayne build, my 16 & 14 Silverados were both Silao made. I don't see much of a difference in fit and finish. My 14 was a vibrator, but I can't blame that on the assembly plant. When I bought my 19 I sought out a U.S. made truck, not because I was unhappy with the quality of the other two, but just because of pride. GM is an American company, and I think they should build as many vehicles here as they can profitably. 

They are supposed to start production of the American version of the truck this month.  I knew a few guys at FCA that strongly admitted that truck is junk due to where it is built.

 

https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2018/jan/18/donald-trump/trump-said-chrysler-leaving-mexico-it-isnt/

ILSilverado Enthusiast

ILSilverado

Posted
Posted

My 2019 was built in Indiana my 2020 in Mexico. The only difference for me was I named the 2020 Carlos!

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
jlong1984 Enthusiast

jlong1984

Posted
Posted
3 hours ago, fatwhiteboy said:

They are supposed to start production of the American version of the truck this month.  I knew a few guys at FCA that strongly admitted that truck is junk due to where it is built.

 

https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2018/jan/18/donald-trump/trump-said-chrysler-leaving-mexico-it-isnt/

That is from January 2018, when the former head of FCA, Sergio Marchionne was still alive. He had planned to move assembly of the new 2019 HD pickups to Michigan. That changed after his death in July of the same year, when Mike Manley took over. 

 

Straight from the Fiat-Chrysler website. 

 

Quote

On Feb. 26, 2019, FCA confirmed that the investment announced in 2017 will increase to $1.5 billion and include tooling to produce electrified versions of the Jeep Wagoneer and Grand Wagoneer. As part of the announcement, the Company also confirmed that production of the Ram 1500 Classic will continue. It is expected that 1,400 new jobs will be added. With this announcement, production of the all-new Ram Heavy Duty will continue at its current location in Saltillo, Mexico. (FCA had announced in January 2018 that heavy duty production would move from Saltillo, Mexico, to Warren.)

https://media.fcanorthamerica.com/newsrelease.do?id=343

  • 2 years later...
Samuel Daniels New Member

Samuel Daniels

Posted
Posted

The quality system put in place are at all GM and GMC plants.  There is only one quality system and plenty of cross checking between plants to maintain consistency.  After 40 years in the automotive parts manufacturing business and supplying to GM,  I know 1st hand the difficulty in getting and maintaining their QS certification which is necessary to do business with them.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 1
Peter land Enthusiast

Peter land

Posted
Posted
On 1/14/2020 at 9:04 PM, diyer2 said:

I think the build location is a non factor.

It's the luck of the draw.

This is true with every product we buy IMO.

You get a good one or you don't.

:)

Agreed 100%. 

  • Like 1
  • 4 months later...
codeman11 New Member

codeman11

Posted
Posted (edited)

I have no experience within the factories, but I can chime in and say that the interior quality issues in a made in Mexico GM seems to be true, at least in my case. I have a '22 refresh, Sierra Denali. Interior trim fitment issues, and screws improperly fastened to the point where some of the plastic tabs have cracked / enlarged the holes.

 

That has to do with a worker and proper QC ... sorry but there is some truth to variations in quality when coming from different factories. Morale and average IQ play a role no matter where you go. Perhaps the US factory has more laziness, perhaps it's Mexico - who knows. But where there's a human element, you can't honestly claim things are 100% the same. That's just plain stupidity.

Edited by codeman11
  • Like 1
dieselfan1 Senior Enthusiast

dieselfan1

Posted
Posted

I've had a Mexican 2018 and a Fort Wayne 2018.

The Mexican truck needed the bed realigned and both rear doors were mis aligned.

Paint on the Mexican was sub par IMO.

The ft Wayne 2018 didn't have these issues.

Now I have 2 Ft Wayne 2022 LTDs a high country and an LTZ.  Neither have these issues.

I think the Mexican plant just slaps them together and not much QC going on. I think they have no pride in their work. The Fort Wayne folks do take pride in their work. Fact.

 

gt tangerine Enthusiast

gt tangerine

Posted
Posted

My Mexican refresh AT4 has the best paint I’ve had on a GM truck. My last was a 21 Silao built LT trail boss and the two before that were both Ft Wayne. For what it’s worth I would have rather had a US built truck but I have to admit the refresh I received is extremely well put together. No rattles no bed alignment issues 

Churchill729 Enthusiast

Churchill729

Posted
Posted (edited)

I purchased a 2022 Silverado that was made in Silao. 
 

I’ve been happy with it so far. Quality seems fine to me. 
 

I did find the attached checklist rolled up and wedged in the suspension. Kind of a neat tie in to the worker who assembled it. 

BFDCD591-CBEE-4E72-853D-B9712B1510F9.jpeg

Edited by Churchill729
Typo

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • garagerog
      Low fuel pressure after installing new fuel pump

      By garagerog · Posted

      Replace the fuel pump with an OEM AC-Delco.
    • Gilkey96
      Low fuel pressure after installing new fuel pump

      By Gilkey96 · Posted

      Hello, first time posting here. I have an 03 Chevy 1500HD with the 6 liter gas engine. The truck ran fine until the fuel pump died on me and had to get it towed. Replaced the fuel pump with a precision pump from O’rileys and changed the fuel filter while I was there. The truck will run and drive now but it wants to idle around 500 rpm when in drive and it tries to stall if you touch the gas. It drives fine though, just doesn’t want to idle. Put a fuel pressure gauge on the rail and only have 50 psi. I guess these trucks should have 55-62 psi to run right. I thought the regulator might be the issue because when I would unplug the vacuum hose it jumped to 56 psi. Replaced the regulator and no change. The only thing I can think of is that I was sold a faulty fuel pump. Any help would be appreciated because I’d rather not have to take the bed off again if I don’t have too. Thank you!
    • diyer2
      AFM Experience

      By diyer2 · Posted

      I've been wrenching on GM trucks for 17 years. And I need to get something off my chest because it's been weighing on me for a long time. After all that time, all those motors, all those people standing in my bay, I've figured out there are really only two kinds of owners. The ones who already know about this. And the ones who are about to find out the hard way. A guy came into my shop a few weeks back in a 2018 Silverado 5.3. Sharp guy, maybe 35. Knew his truck cold. He'd been on the forums, read the threads, done his homework. He only rolled in so I could double-check a little module he'd already plugged in himself. Wanted a second set of eyes on it. Ten minutes, in and out, drove off happy. Two days later, a completely different story walked through the same door. Older fella this time, in a 2016 Sierra. Gorgeous truck, clearly babied, not a scratch on it. Wedding ring. Looked like a guy who took care of his stuff. He was in because his engine had started knocking on the way to work. And by the time I got the valve cover off, I already knew it was too late. Lifter collapsed. Cylinder 5. Camshaft chewed up. The whole top end shot. Same kind of truck. Same motor. Same roads, probably the same dealer. The only thing separating those two men was information. I've been at this since 2008, and I've worked on everything GM puts out. Silverados. Sierras. Tahoes. Yukons. Suburbans. Escalades. The 5.3 and the 6.2. Doesn't matter which badge is on the tailgate. They all carry the same problem. So here's the information one of those guys had and the other one didn't. It's called Active Fuel Management. AFM. GM started building it into their V6s and V8s back in 2007 to squeeze out a little better mileage on the highway. Maybe a mile or two a gallon. All to hit government fuel economy numbers. The way it works, the motor quietly shuts down half its cylinders when you're just cruising along. And the little lifters that pull that off have a tiny pin inside them that's constantly clicking in and out. Lock, unlock, lock, unlock. Hundreds of times a drive. Thousands of times a week. Eventually one of those pins wears through. The lifter drops. And it starts grinding the camshaft down like a chisel on butter. And what nobody tells you is that the shudder you feel around 40 or 50 mph? That's the system cycling. Every single time. Here's what really gets me. The pre-2007 trucks, the ones without AFM, they're bulletproof. I've got customers still daily driving them with 260,000 miles on the odometer. Not a problem in the world. GM took a perfectly good motor that would have lasted a lifetime and bolted this system onto it. And it is wrecking engines that should have run forever. The guys who hang around the forums already know all of this. So do the techs. They handled this years ago. They didn't sit around waiting for the dealership to mail them a warning letter, because that letter is never coming. It's the guys who figured somebody would've told them who end up on my lift. And I want to be clear, because this part matters. Maintenance has nothing to do with it. I've torn down motors with barely 30,000 miles on the clock. I pulled apart a Tahoe last summer with 24,000 on it. Practically a brand new truck. Owner had it less than a year. Spotless oil. Best synthetic money can buy, changed early every time. Made no difference. I've seen guys with full dealer records, every interval stamped. Made no difference. The oil changes were never the problem. The pin was. And no amount of babying that truck stops that pin from cycling every single time you drive. That's the part that eats at me. These are good motors. Take the AFM out of the equation and a 5.3 or a 6.2 will run 300,000 miles and never blink. So a few years ago I started telling every single owner who comes through my doors the exact same thing the smart guys already knew. Get yourself a FullForce disabler. It plugs right into the port under your dash. Couple of seconds and you're done. It just tells the computer to leave every cylinder running, full time. No more cycling. No more beating those lifters back and forth every time you turn the key. It doesn't reprogram anything. Doesn't touch your tune. And unplug it before a dealer visit and there's absolutely zero trace it was ever installed. I've had customers come back at 40,000, 60,000, 80,000 miles after I put one in. Zero issues. The trucks run smoother. And the lifters aren't getting beaten to death every single drive. I won't sit here and tell you it's magic. A lifter that's already damaged is a lifter that's already damaged, and this won't un-ring that bell. But it takes away the one thing causing all that wear in the first place. That's the whole game. You don't need a five-thousand-dollar delete. You don't need an expensive tune. You don't need to tear anything apart. You just need to stop the cycling. I'm not writing this for any company. I'm writing it because I'm tired of watching the guys who didn't know pay four and five figures for it. I'm tired of being the guy who has to break the news. I'm tired of knowing that the guys who did know fixed the whole thing for the price of a tank of gas, and the only difference was that somebody told them first. If you drive a Silverado, Sierra, Tahoe, Yukon, Suburban, or Escalade from 2007 or newer with a V6 or V8, you've got AFM. You've got those lifters, and they're cycling every single time you drive. So be the guy who already knew. Not the one I'm scraping metal out of next month. EDIT: A bunch of folks asked, so here it is. The one I put my faith in is FullForce. This is where to find it: https://www.tryfullforce.com/products/fullforce™-afm-dfm-disabler They back it with a 60-day guarantee too. I've handed out more than I can count and not one's ever come back to me. Not one. See less
    • Atlas
      Wow I'm in a pickle. (Broke down truck) and a story.

      By Atlas · Posted

      Thanks for following along. I'm not author material, my tenses are all over the place and an editor would have a heck of a time cleaning up after me. Reading and writing is still a fun pastime though.   My new scanner came in yesterday, wow, where the heck has this thing been?! It connects right up to the Blazer, there's all kinds of bidirectional tests like EGR activation and percentage, toggle the fuel pump relay, EVAP purge valve, IAC control, AC relay, reset the transmission's adaptive learning, toggle shift solenoids and TCC lockup, and I can reset fuel trims with the click of a button...all things I could have used over the last 60 days!   It's also telling me there is a stored code in the ABS module for front left wheel sensor open and something about the brake switch. The ABS dash light works. It illuminates normally during the self-test at key on/ start and that's it. I cleared the codes and will see if they set when I take it out later. That, and I'm going to get (hopefully) real data on timing and cam ******. The PID's are there.   I connected the tool to my truck...holy smokes. Newer vehicles make early OBDII vehicles look like 8-bit, pixelated, early Nintendo stuff. This? This is like wearing 3D virtual reality goggles playing one of those elaborate, cinematic video games with seasons and plots in comparison. There are SO MANY modules and SO MANY tests and SO MUCH data. There's a scanner sequence for filling the coolant...   End of the day, it's a tool with way more power than I need, but the versatility to do old and new is there (and I need an adapter to connect it to my OBDI Camaro). It will allow me to do the first pass of diagnosis when out-of-warranty vehicles need help, and it will enable more DIY maintenance like brake system bleeding, ABS bleed, etc. I probably over-bought here, but, mission is accomplished.   Enjoy your Sunday...I need to shut this machine down and go get ready for the week ahead.
    • MORSNO
      Which 2027 engine will you choose?

      By MORSNO · Posted

      Not that I've read, after all the issues they've had in the past I'm pretty sure they learned their lesson. 

  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...