Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

I am just surprised NOT one person from GM can tell me which lifters are typically the problem, or if its any lifter at any given time. I need to decide on replacing all of the ones that aren't bad while the engine is apart. If the new ones go bad; then screw it; what's the point? They said the part numbers are different but WHAT CAUSED THIS ISSUE IN THE FIRST PLACE???!!! Replacing broken parts doesn't fix the issue if the lifter the victim of something else being wrong. Should they check the oil pump too? Or are the new lifters improved???! I can't get an fricking answer from anyone. Its like a conspiracy

Posted

Totally hear ya. What a friggin joke. Hope you get the answers someplace ...

Posted

Got the call today after the 6.2 in my 2010 Yukon Denali was completely torn down. Collapsed lifter which ruined the rocker and the push rod. Unreal! Luckily I am not flipping the bill since I just bought it. I am paying $300 parts only to replace the remaining lifters with new ones so avoid this disaster in the future. Everything else checks out fine and pressure was checked. Oil pump is fine too. This could have been a major disaster down the road. GM so far has done nothing to fix this. $65,000 SUV...how do they expect me to buy a brand new one after this! The Ford dealer I bought it from is paying for GMs mistake just to make things right with me. Maybe I need to switch?!

Posted (edited)

Got the call today after the 6.2 in my 2010 Yukon Denali was completely torn down. Collapsed lifter which ruined the rocker and the push rod. Unreal! Luckily I am not flipping the bill since I just bought it. I am paying $300 parts only to replace the remaining lifters with new ones so avoid this disaster in the future. Everything else checks out fine and pressure was checked. Oil pump is fine too. This could have been a major disaster down the road. GM so far has done nothing to fix this. $65,000 SUV...how do they expect me to buy a brand new one after this! The Ford dealer I bought it from is paying for GMs mistake just to make things right with me. Maybe I need to switch?!

I am here after owning 2 F150's, both having transmission issues. The tranny in the 05 failed at 66K miles. It also had a couple injectors fail at two different times. The second time it took out one converter. At 5K miles the complete sunroof assembly and headliner had to be replaced after 2 previous repair attempts. The dealer finally replaced everything when it got stuck opened.

 

Pick your poison :thumbs:

Edited by EX-F150 owner
Posted (edited)

Everything is junk today. You can't win!

 

Best course of action is to buy something built 40 years ago, and install modern components on it yourself. Wish I had taken my own advice. I was an idiot, and bought an '07 Silverado back in '07. I've done just as much repair work to this thing as I have to cars 4 decades older!

Edited by Jsdirt
Posted

Got the call today after the 6.2 in my 2010 Yukon Denali was completely torn down. Collapsed lifter which ruined the rocker and the push rod. Unreal! Luckily I am not flipping the bill since I just bought it. I am paying $300 parts only to replace the remaining lifters with new ones so avoid this disaster in the future. Everything else checks out fine and pressure was checked. Oil pump is fine too. This could have been a major disaster down the road. GM so far has done nothing to fix this. $65,000 SUV...how do they expect me to buy a brand new one after this! The Ford dealer I bought it from is paying for GMs mistake just to make things right with me. Maybe I need to switch?!

 

How many miles were on it when you bought it?

Were you able to obtain service records for it?

Anything show up when running the VIN at a GM dealership?

  • 1 month later...
Posted (edited)

So I have a weird one for you guys. Only when the truck is cold when I start it there is a very loud thunk noise, but only 1. It doesn't need to 'warm' up to go away. It literally goes away after 1 revolution (or close to). I've listened to probably 20 youtube videos of cold piston slap and it definitely doesn't sound like that. It almost sounds like a metal on metal thwack. Hard to explain. I'll have to get a video of it later today after the vehicle cools down.

Doesn't do it in +5 degree temp and doesn't do it once the block is warmed. Like I said there is only 1 quick noise and that is it. Not sure what it is.

Edited by Cosworth
Posted

So I have a weird one for you guys. Only when the truck is cold when I start it there is a very loud thunk noise, but only 1. It doesn't need to 'warm' up to go away. It literally goes away after 1 revolution (or close to). I've listened to probably 20 youtube videos of cold piston slap and it definitely doesn't sound like that. It almost sounds like a metal on metal thwack. Hard to explain. I'll have to get a video of it later today after the vehicle cools down.

Doesn't do it in +5 degree temp and doesn't do it once the block is warmed. Like I said there is only 1 quick noise and that is it. Not sure what it is.

 

Well gauge was showing below the lowest line and it didn't do it. But it was parked on the street and I manually started it. I always remote start the truck when I am on my way out in the morning. So I'll try and manually start it tomorrow after sitting. I wonder if it is a lifter noise because the oil bleeds out of it?

Posted

So had a chance to start it this morning. Luckily it doesnt sound like a metallic noise like I thought, it more sounds like a snuff noise. Almost like a valve cover breather. Kind of strange. Thoughts?

 

 

Posted

Tough over the net ... but it sounds like it may have an exhaust manifold leak where it meets the pipe. I think it might be after the cat on these new ones - can't remember. I think that's how mine is. Might just get away with tightening the bolts if that's indeed where the sound is coming from ...

 

It would go away when warm, I would think, if it was an exhaust leak that small.

Posted

So had a chance to start it this morning. Luckily it doesnt sound like a metallic noise like I thought, it more sounds like a snuff noise. Almost like a valve cover breather. Kind of strange. Thoughts?

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qz5eLBfJTwQ

Mine has had that noise (only when below freezing) since new so 6 yrs now. It has not concerned me as I remember my old 2000 having a similar sound

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Posted

Tough over the net ... but it sounds like it may have an exhaust manifold leak where it meets the pipe. I think it might be after the cat on these new ones - can't remember. I think that's how mine is. Might just get away with tightening the bolts if that's indeed where the sound is coming from ...

 

It would go away when warm, I would think, if it was an exhaust leak that small.

 

Awesome, so not going to throw a pushrod through the intake, that is all I care at this point. haha

 

Mine has had that noise (only when below freezing) since new so 6 yrs now. It has not concerned me as I remember my old 2000 having a similar sound

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

Good to know, yeah the first couple times it sounded violent but now it sounds like just a crap load of air being sucked in. Glad to know it isn't me and/or a sign of impending failure.

Posted

Sounds like the starter bendix is sticking. And probably doesn't do it when warm because the grease is warmer.

 

 

Sent from the future via a wifi time portal.

Posted

Sounds like the starter bendix is sticking. And probably doesn't do it when warm because the grease is warmer.

 

 

Sent from the future via a wifi time portal.

 

That could very well be it as well. If that happens to be it, what would be worst case that one day it wouldn't disengage? Shouldn't cause much more than starter failure I would imagine (which really isn't a huge deal in the scheme of things).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Latest Articles

  • Posts

    • Congratulations Isttype, on your gmc. Really like my 2024 2500hd sle doublecab now with 85,500 miles.  I checked the oil today at 4800 miles since last oil change and barely reading on the stick.  I don't care if GM says it's Acceptable adding a quart every 2000 miles because that is 100% BS, It is not a 1966 Harley Shovelhead! Sounds like it's setting up a future failure like I had with my 1500 6.2l. Other than oil consumption problems, I really like the 6.6l gas and 10 speed is really nice.  Towed a light 4000 pound trailer last week and averaged 14 mpg.  I was pretty impressive that a 7300 pound gas truck did 14mpg towing, Later-
    • Long Term Cold Cycle Limited Testing   Back to the 1990's and XOM's million mile test. Since then there have been others and there will be more. Schaeffer's, AMSOIL to name two. Of these Schaeffer's is the stand alone which I will explain in a bit later.    http://papers.sae.org/600190/:   http://papers.sae.org/850215/:   Up to 75% of  engine wear occurs on cold starts. These two links (above) provide the technical reasons for engine wear. In a nut shell, and by a large margin, cylinder wear is what takes out most motors and even with a pre-oiling system that part of the engine is dry enough on cold starts and cold warm up to pierce Stribeck.   So when you put a motor, or a car, on a dyno for a million miles stopping only for oil changes, (yes fuel is uninterrupted) or break down maintenance, you are depriving the test of the most important part of it's wear cycle. Yes a million is then a pretty easy walk even for a mineral oil under those conditions.    How about cleanliness during the long test cycles? Same thing. Varnishes that stick rings and insulate parts are laid down by repetitive 'heat cycles'. It's the cool down the precipitates the varnishes. These long runs also hinder acidic attack caused by cold start richness and less than optimal cold start ring sealing. They hinder water formation and enhance breathing of the crankcase; the petri dish of acid formation, the first step in sludge formation, amalgamation and precipitation. These motors are also monitored and controlled for water and oil temperatures to within the "normal operating range".      https://www.swri.org/sites/default/files/sequence-iiih-test.pdf Note the test sequence in some boutique oils literature for testing, API IIIH, is not the standard used for the ILSAC G7 testing. Does that mean it is irrelevant? No, not as used. As used as a 'visual guide' it makes it's point. The G7 weighted piston deposit minimum is lower.      Back to Schaeffer's. That was a cyclical test of an engine in fleet service and not a dyno mule and if you saw the video it was not mirror clean but wear was low.    There are oils like BioSyn and other 'Renewable" source oils that taught cleanliness and have proven themselves in fleet testing. Havoline an other example.    The newest ILSAC G-7 test prioritize cleanliness, LSPI mitigation and fuel economy OVER WEAR. In comparison Porsche C30 Specification Verses ILSAC G-7 Specification below:      Some will balk that this graph isn't apples to apples and I will challenge that in that this graph represent the SPECIFICATION and not the any One Oil Performance.   It is absolutely possible to minimize wear, maximize cleanliness and mitigate LSPI etc., It just isn't cheap and currently I see none that are not walking toward profit over performance.     
    • I don't think you will need a split, separate product, etc., the OBD port should be able to deliver everything you need. Since your device would be plugged into it all the time, it wouldn't miss anything.    Hardware in this case will be the easiest part of your project - ELM 327 devices will already deliver all the data you need. Reporting/software is where your advantage/marketability is.
    • I do too. I’ll never be stuck again 😂
    • It has happened to me a few times. I carry a jumpstart-tire inflator with me.
  • GM-Trucks.com Clubs

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...